IF_MS_BUYS_GITHUB_IMMA_OUT icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
IF_MS_BUYS_GITHUB_IMMA_OUT copied to clipboard

This repo isn't in weekly trends

Open XakepSDK opened this issue 6 years ago • 34 comments

Just look at this: 3400++ starts in 4 days and this repo now isn't in trending list. a Micrototalitarism from microsoft.

XakepSDK avatar Jun 06 '18 06:06 XakepSDK

This is called censorship. It isn't in daily trends, too.

schmidt1024 avatar Jun 06 '18 06:06 schmidt1024

No, this is called paranoia...

image

zskovacs avatar Jun 06 '18 06:06 zskovacs

Wtf, i can't find it

XakepSDK avatar Jun 06 '18 06:06 XakepSDK

It is found in https://github.com/explore, but not in https://github.com/trending?since=weekly

XakepSDK avatar Jun 06 '18 07:06 XakepSDK

They clearly had someone to take it out. Because this was rather embarrassing.

vassudanagunta avatar Jun 06 '18 07:06 vassudanagunta

The trending repos work in funny ways, and it's been known to drop repos that are consistently popular some times to let others shine.

EDIT: https://web.archive.org/web/20180606080036/https://github.com/upend/IF_MS_BUYS_GITHUB_IMMA_OUT/issues/88

Omeryl avatar Jun 06 '18 07:06 Omeryl

@Omeryl That isn't likely because ry / deno has been on that board before this group, and was along side us this entire time.

vassudanagunta avatar Jun 06 '18 07:06 vassudanagunta

You should not censor comments.

e-kwsm avatar Jun 06 '18 07:06 e-kwsm

Already on HN: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17245018

nukeop avatar Jun 06 '18 08:06 nukeop

This group is like a big meeting. This meeting has a specific agenda. It is not a "free speech" meeting. There are plenty of places for free speech.

Debates about which GitHub alternative, or about whether an image I posted was insensitive to women are on topic and very welcome. Posts by people opposed to this group or its aims don't belong here. Their only purpose is to undermine this group. They can do that anywhere else but here.

I've only had 3 hours of sleep for four nights in a row, and zero so far tonight (4:30am). I'm doing the best I can to keep this project on track.

vassudanagunta avatar Jun 06 '18 08:06 vassudanagunta

The "insensitive to women" thing is a classic derailment tactic employed by trolls. You should not have responded to it, or yielded to their demands.

nukeop avatar Jun 06 '18 08:06 nukeop

I just updated the homepage (README) with the news about the Microsoft censorship.

vassudanagunta avatar Jun 06 '18 08:06 vassudanagunta

You justify your censorship but abuse MS's? (I don't think MS/GH censors.)

e-kwsm avatar Jun 06 '18 08:06 e-kwsm

You are abusing other peoples opinion by editing and removing comments that don't fit your opinion.

"Without any moderation at all, this repo will turn into a pile of shit very fast." This is not moderation, this is censorship.

Droppers avatar Jun 06 '18 08:06 Droppers

Without any moderation at all, this repo will turn into a pile of shit very fast.

> This is not moderation, this is censorship. I think the difference here is very thin.

MoonlightOwl avatar Jun 06 '18 09:06 MoonlightOwl

@Droppers This repo has a clear purpose and it makes sense to remove threads that aren't relevant to that. It doesn't stop you from finding an alternative or using both. That is the freedom we have on this platform, to provide an opportunity for all views but requiring all people to accept them.

In short, it cuts both ways.

RyanGannon avatar Jun 06 '18 09:06 RyanGannon

@RyanGannon I agree with that, but removing or editing any counter-argument is not helping anyone.

This repository has a bad reputation because of this.

Droppers avatar Jun 06 '18 09:06 Droppers

And there goes Github's sense of humour (among other things).

thrasos avatar Jun 06 '18 09:06 thrasos

@Omeryl, @e-kwsm, @Droppers and anyone else who dislikes my censorship. I created a space for you guys to express your disagreement: #91.

If you guys self-delete your comments about censorship from here and other places and promise to keep them within #91, then you can have that forum. Deal? That's the best I can do.

vassudanagunta avatar Jun 06 '18 09:06 vassudanagunta

前排兜售香烟瓜子火腿肠啤酒饮料

HExiangyu avatar Jun 06 '18 11:06 HExiangyu

I got it in my "trending repos" daily email 🤷‍♂️

screen shot 2018-06-06 at 9 25 45 am

Careful not to get too knee-jerky.

ajacksified avatar Jun 06 '18 13:06 ajacksified

@ajacksified That email is outdated, its been 2000+ stars for atleast a day

Leprecorn avatar Jun 06 '18 14:06 Leprecorn

It was literally from an hour ago.

On Wed, Jun 6, 2018, 10:23 AM Leprecorn [email protected] wrote:

@ajacksified https://github.com/ajacksified That email is outdated, its been 2000+ stars for atleast a day

— You are receiving this because you were mentioned. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/upend/IF_MS_BUYS_GITHUB_IMMA_OUT/issues/88#issuecomment-395086903, or mute the thread https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AAKtmxnqLDv4q3ycZgeXaNAPsGauh0yiks5t5-XqgaJpZM4UcFE- .

ajacksified avatar Jun 06 '18 14:06 ajacksified

US here, cannot see it anywhere

Flarp avatar Jun 06 '18 14:06 Flarp

I am far from an expert, but I think it is very plausible that this project falls in the gray area of GitHub TOS (see 2 and 3 of acceptable use). So, wouldn't it be reasonable to expect someone at GitHub simply removed it from the github.com/trending as a silent warning?

jorgebucaran avatar Jun 06 '18 15:06 jorgebucaran

Also, check out the developer Ranks. How is Nadela Ranked as No.1? I mean, WTF?

image

kuharan avatar Jun 06 '18 18:06 kuharan

@kuharan I think the only reason he's showing up there is that a lot of users happen to be following his account. Not at all odd considering recent events. It's just an algorithm.

jorgebucaran avatar Jun 06 '18 23:06 jorgebucaran

This reminds me https://www.theregister.co.uk/AMP/2016/04/15/microsoft_discontinues_robovm/. The M$ guy who discontinued a rival open source project is exactly the same guy in charge of Github.

hktonylee avatar Jun 07 '18 06:06 hktonylee

Hey all. I love the work you've been doing. Not everyone loves mine. Please read Issue 114.

vassudanagunta avatar Jun 07 '18 21:06 vassudanagunta

Below is the history of our star count and trending rank based on the Git log of our README, which was publicly updated with stars and rank until they buried us. The last row in the table is when we discovered we were not on the list anymore. The drop in rank was a cliff drop. There is no other explanation other than censorship.

If someone can make a time series plot of the second column, and annotate it with rank, it will be really obvious. It will show an upwardly accelerating curve for number of stars, and then we're cut off.

time (Eastern) stars trending rank
2018-06-04 8:24:36 1000 3
2018-06-04 9:43:23 1100 2
2018-06-04 12:10:47 1400 2
2018-06-04 15:22:33 1600 2
2018-06-04 21:28:56 1800 1
2018-06-05 0:52:06 2000 1
2018-06-05 3:02:11 2100 1
2018-06-06 4:47:04 3300 1
2018-06-06 5:51:00 3400  

vassudanagunta avatar Jun 08 '18 16:06 vassudanagunta