James Bennett

> API: I am squeamish about putting a third-party network call in core features like login because of latency, outages, importance, autonomy. I'm aware it can all be Done Properly...

I think for the specific problems that have been raised here, there are multiple possible solutions and it feels like there's room to discuss what the best solutions would be....

@tim-schilling maybe a different way of phrasing this is: To you, it's clear what this proposal is about, what its goals are, what problems it aims to solve, why it...

> careful wording, lots of rationale, and back-and-forth discussions on relevant points of the proposal Well, the PR description mentions things like (to pick one example) why self-nomination was chosen...