ad-detector icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
ad-detector copied to clipboard

Update styles for cleaner look

Open dantewashere opened this issue 10 years ago • 4 comments

The red is a bit harsh and cleaner typography could help. Also, considering trying to add styling to the "ad-detector" badge (so that it's more official) and "X" button is more of a button and intuitive to the user.

[Full disclosure: I'm an Art Director for The Atlantic and we think about these things a lot from a readers perspective. I love this idea and would like to help develop a standard that balances user experience with full transparency]

dantewashere avatar Sep 02 '14 16:09 dantewashere

Thanks for this. It definitely looks better, but I'm nervous about toning down the harshness of the red. Do you think it's possible that users could ignore a toned-down banner at the top of the page (a bit like ad blindness)?

typpo avatar Sep 05 '14 22:09 typpo

I wonder if we could make it feel even more integrated with the web browser itself, so it's more of a notification. I don't think it will be easily ignored because it's fixed to the top of the viewport at all times (unless you close it). There is definitely a balance between transparency and a message that visually says "warning: stay away from this".

dantewashere avatar Sep 05 '14 22:09 dantewashere

Ultimately, I'm envisioning this plugin being adopted as a standard by all web browser makers. It's something that could benefit everyone and force the buzzfeeds of the world to not mislead people.

dantewashere avatar Sep 05 '14 22:09 dantewashere

Perhaps a more browsery look would help, for example if the style were similar to Chrome notification banners? This may antagonize publishers less while avoiding the blindness issue.

example image

Unfortunately there are ads/bad sites that mimic this pattern. I want to be careful to not fall in that category.

typpo avatar Sep 08 '14 22:09 typpo