Atul Tulshibagwale

Results 58 comments of Atul Tulshibagwale

Hi @pja-ant , Here are a few thoughts: - Stateless: There can probably be no negotiation in a stateless protocol, so if we're thinking of going stateless (for other reasons),...

> connor4312 I've pushed a commit that addresses the "language" and "profile lifetime" questions. For the other two questions: - Profiles may be custom defined, and not governed by MCP,...

Providing an example here, which was previously discussed in the Discord server: An example of why we need profiles could be (as Paul points out) that an organization (say “Wholesale...

Seems reasonable. You haven't marked this for v3, so would you like this to be addressed right now, or after v3?

This is great, thanks for putting this together! A few minor comments: - In the recommended extensions paragraph, the line: > This recommendation can be removed at any time. Could...

@pja-ant I thought about extension discovery a bit, and I think there might be an issue with discovering details of an extension. Say a server card indicates that it supports...

@pja-ant , thanks. Would the list of recommended extensions include their description URLs?

Interesting proposal. I am on board with the major and minor version numbers of this Semantic Versioning scheme for the specification part, and the entire scheme for the SDK part....