connection refused

[chrisuhg]

i can make sure the container has access the internet, but why it always connect to localhost ?

[ttionya]

It's impossible to get relevant information from the description alone, please provide the logs during the backup.

[Capobuf]

Same issue here!

I've tried also with the other format but i've received same results!

@ttionya how we can provide you the logs? You refer to the logs showing in console during backup?

This is what i see (i think that dead letter it's my previous attempt to debug)

My SMTP ENV:

MAIL_SMTP_ENABLE="TRUE" MAIL_SMTP_VARIABLES=" -S v15-compat -S smtp-use-starttls -S mta=smtp://smtp-relay.gmail.com:587 -S [email protected]" MAIL_TO="[email protected]" MAIL_WHEN_SUCCESS="TRUE" MAIL_WHEN_FAILURE="TRUE"

Thanks a lot!

[ttionya]

@Capobuf ,

I'm not sure why this error is occurring. What is the host machine you are using?

[Capobuf]

@Capobuf ,

I'm not sure why this error is occurring. What is the host machine you are using?

It's a VMWare VM, with Ubuntu Server 22.04

[Lenart12]

I got the same error but maybe different issue. I think its problem of parsing the enviroment variable. Writing a little test script I think I figured out a possible fix:

#!/usr/bin/env bash

# Just simulate what sendmail sees
function show_each_arg() {
    for arg in "$@"; do
        echo "[$arg]"
    done
}

# Sample usage, doesnt make sense but just to show there is issue with single quotes
TEST_VAR="-S 'mta=smtp://smtp.gmail.com:587 smtp-use-starttls' -S smtp-use-starttls -S smtp-auth=login"

# THIS IS WHAT WE EXPECT/WANT
show_each_arg -S 'mta=smtp://smtp.gmail.com:587 smtp-use-starttls' -S smtp-use-starttls -S smtp-auth=login
# [-S]
# [mta=smtp://smtp.gmail.com:587 smtp-use-starttls]
# [-S]
# [smtp-use-starttls]
# [-S]
# [smtp-auth=login]


# THIS IS WHAT WE GET
show_each_arg $TEST_VAR
# [-S]
# ['mta=smtp://smtp.gmail.com:587] # <- `mta` is never set! instead `'mta` starting with ' is set 
# [smtp-use-starttls'] # This gets parsed as a positional argument!
# [-S]
# [smtp-use-starttls]
# [-S]
# [smtp-auth=login]


# POSSIBLE FIX
eval "show_each_arg $TEST_VAR"
# [-S]
# [mta=smtp://smtp.gmail.com:587 smtp-use-starttls]
# [-S]
# [smtp-use-starttls]
# [-S]
# [smtp-auth=login]

Fix should be here: https://github.com/ttionya/vaultwarden-backup/blob/d138633929911c564242af13ad75bc8b76b9e8ef/scripts/includes.sh#L107

Maybe

echo "$2" | eval "mail ${MAIL_VERBOSE} -s \"$1\" ${MAIL_SMTP_VARIABLES} \"${MAIL_TO}\""

EDIT: Also want to add this. I think connection refused with 127.0.0.1 means that smtp or mta was not set correctly and is trying to connect to default smtp which is localhost.

[ttionya]

@Lenart12 ,

Thank you for your reply.

If there are spaces after mta= in the configuration, it might cause issues. I don't know the value of your MAIL_SMTP_VARIABLES environment variable, but in the configuration -S v15-compat -S smtp-use-starttls -S mta=smtp://smtp-relay.gmail.com:587 -S [email protected] provided by the user who reported this issue, there are no spaces after mta=. Therefore, I believe this might not be the cause.

If possible, please perform an mail test. This uses the same function calls as during the backup and will display more detailed information when debug mode is enabled. Additionally, I'd like to know your server's connectivity to smtp.gmail.com. You can check this by running the command nslookup smtp.gmail.com and sharing the output. This information will help me troubleshoot and resolve the issue.

Thank you!

[Lenart12]

The values I provided were just demonstrational, I have my own mail server. I got my smtp working fine after I removed spaces and quotes from mail variables.

This means I need to use old -S smtp= syntax and cant use -S 'mta= because it requires spaces and also I can't set sender name with -S 'from=Vaultwarden backup <[email protected]>'.

If you want I can make seperate issue for this.

[ttionya]

@Lenart12 , This will indeed cause a problem, I will fix it, please create a new issue for this. Thank you.