PieMenu icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
PieMenu copied to clipboard

[PieMenu] Create an SVG icon for this addon

Open luzpaz opened this issue 5 years ago • 13 comments

https://github.com/FreeCAD/FreeCAD-addons/issues/37

luzpaz avatar Jun 14 '19 03:06 luzpaz

Hey @triplus ltns
How about this as a logo for this addon ? https://github.com/FreeCAD/FreeCAD-addons/issues/37#issuecomment-502045926

luzpaz avatar Jun 14 '19 11:06 luzpaz

@triplus how does this appeal to you as the Addon logo? pie_menu_v01
courtesy of @pgilfernandez in https://github.com/FreeCAD/FreeCAD-addons/issues/37#issuecomment-502045926

luzpaz avatar Jun 17 '19 18:06 luzpaz

Hi.

I noticed you opened an issue report against all my modules, due to missing SVG icons representing them. As i guess addon manager now supports such icon? Best if i respond here for all modules.

Realistically i don't see missing icon representing a big issue and i will first try to finish the coding related work. After i plan to start working more seriously on aspects such as icon and the documentation.

triplus avatar Jun 18 '19 14:06 triplus

@triplus I opened said issues so that I could track them all through FreeCAD/FreeCAD-addons#37 (I did so for all workbenches). Sorry for the noise. You have a lot on your plate and I appreciate all you do for FC.

Would you be open to me posting requests for others to create icons for you said addon at this time, until your development timeline reaches that point where you can take a look at this in more depth? I'd post them to the FC UI/UX subforum, of course.

Edit: Are you green light with using the above logo to represent this Addon specifically (for the time being)?

luzpaz avatar Jun 18 '19 15:06 luzpaz

I reevaluated you proposal again today and realistically this will have to wait until most of involved modules reaches maturity (code vise). Tasks, such as creating an icon representation and the documentation, that will be persued after.

triplus avatar Jun 19 '19 13:06 triplus

@triplus Sorry, just clarification, you are 'red light' on using a placeholder image (that the community would create) to fill the gap of time until you have reached the moment in your development when you can address this ?

luzpaz avatar Jun 19 '19 13:06 luzpaz

Yes.

triplus avatar Jun 19 '19 13:06 triplus

Do you mind sharing your hesitation to do so?

luzpaz avatar Jun 19 '19 14:06 luzpaz

@triplus is there a possible ETA on icons for this and your other Addons ?

luzpaz avatar Oct 28 '19 17:10 luzpaz

Hello, I think adding an icon could improve the module discovery in the addon manager and facilitate finding it, since there are dozens of addons now.

So I wonder what is the status of this. What is wrong with the icon suggested by @luzpaz?

I can suggest improvement if necessary.

roipoussiere avatar Dec 12 '21 10:12 roipoussiere

@roipoussiere triplus has 'gone dark' since Aug 2020 (which is the last time they were active on the forum). There has been talk of forking the repos belonging to triplus so development can continue.

luzpaz avatar Dec 12 '21 12:12 luzpaz

Ok, thanks for the clarification. Is there a good place on the forum to talk about this? I'm interested, since I would like to contribute to this add-on.

roipoussiere avatar Dec 12 '21 21:12 roipoussiere

It's listed in the README file: https://github.com/triplus/PieMenu#discussion
https://forum.freecadweb.org/viewtopic.php?f=34&t=29108

luzpaz avatar Dec 13 '21 11:12 luzpaz