DDF logic

[dirkwhoffmann]

I wrote a couple of test cases to find out how the DDF circuitry works (i.e., if it was really designed as a state machine or if the visible behaviour is just a combination of some toggling flip-flops).

UAE is pretty close (e.g., by accurately replicating the OCS scanline effect), but it doesn’t seem to be 100% right.

Here are the results of test case: https://github.com/dirkwhoffmann/vAmigaTS/tree/master/Agnus/DDFNEW/single1

Original Amiga 500 (ECS Agnus): 🥰

UAE (ECS Agnus): 😳

The Copper list is pretty simple. Between blocks of normal DDF values, it assigns the same value to DDFSTRT and DDFSTOP. Here is a fraction of the list:

        dc.w	$4801,$FFFE  ; WAIT 
	dc.w	COLOR00, $F00
	dc.w    COLOR01,$B6F
	dc.w    DDFSTRT,LEFT
	dc.w	DDFSTOP,RIGHT
	dc.w	$48D9,$FFFE  ; WAIT 
	dc.w	COLOR00, $000

	dc.w	$4E01,$FFFE  ; WAIT 
	dc.w	COLOR00, $F00
	dc.w    DDFSTRT,$28
	dc.w	DDFSTOP,$28
	dc.w	$4ED9,$FFFE  ; WAIT 
	dc.w	COLOR00, $000

	dc.w	$5401,$FFFE  ; WAIT 
	dc.w	COLOR00, $F00
	dc.w    DDFSTRT,LEFT
	dc.w	DDFSTOP,RIGHT
	dc.w	$54D9,$FFFE  ; WAIT 
	dc.w	COLOR00, $000

	dc.w	$5A01,$FFFE  ; WAIT 
	dc.w	COLOR00, $F00
	dc.w    DDFSTRT,$30 
	dc.w	DDFSTOP,$30
	dc.w	$5AD9,$FFFE  ; WAIT 
	dc.w	COLOR00, $000

Overall, the DDF logic seems to be tricky. Yet I cannot explain at all what I see on the real machine. What UAE produces seems to be logical to me, but the real Agnus must follow some other, more esoteric rules.

[tonioni]

It is tricky. I have comment in UAE that says ECS DDSTOP wins if DDSTRT has same value (OCS = DDFSTRT wins) but it probably is only true when DDFSTRT has already matched and DDFSTRT was changed later in scanline. (This isn't that rare in demos, mostly accidental bugs in copper lists..) Behavior probably is different if DDFSTRT hasn't yet matched during the scanline.

OCS almost certainly has state machine that can't skip states and also DDFSTRT/STOP comparisons are only active if vertical display window is open (DIWSTRT/STOP matched) . ECS (and AGA) is simpler, no display window requirement, also possibly just inactive/active state flip-flops like you said. I am not sure why they changed it, probably related to ECS only programmed modes needing more flexibility.

(btw, about your test programs, could you also wrap your test programs in some good system take over routine to make them more compatible with different KS versions etc. At least LoadView(0)+2*WaitTOF() and disable all interrupts and DMA and then enable only required interrupts and DMA)

[dirkwhoffmann]

At least LoadView(0)+2*WaitTOF()

I've never written any 68000 assembler code back in the day. Therefore this sounds a little Chinese to me. I guess 2*WaitTOF() means that my code should wait two frames until it does something (TOF = top of frame)? 🤔 But what does LoadView(0) mean? 😶

I'll try to work on my tool-chain. Maybe I can produce better suited test programs with the Amiga Assembly VSC plug-in...

[tonioni]

They are graphics.library functions. Here are some links to example code: http://eab.abime.net/showthread.php?t=99010

graphics.library/LoadView(0) tells AmigaOS to switch off current mode, set chipset defaults. (=no RTG, no AGA special modes etc.. safe state for taking over the system)

[tonioni]

DDFSTRT==DDFSTOP seems to set internal logic to some kind of impossible state (for example both start and stop is active at the same time or something like that) because even if copper sets DDFSTRT or DDFSTOP to value later in scanline after first DDFSTRT/STOP value has matched, it won't affect current line at all, DDFSTRT/STOP logic seems to be stuck (normally in ECS you can have multiple DDFSTRT/STOP sections in single scanline. OCS does not support it. Demo Subtle Shades/Nuance. ECS=correct graphics. OCS=corrupted). Only following line works as expected. So I assume this impossible state only gets cleared when next scanline starts (or $18 special positions is reached)

EDIT: Forcing DDFSTOP match again (for example if DDFSTRT=$40,DDFSTOP=$40, wait for hpos>$40, set DDFSTOP=$80), when hpos reaches $80, stuck stop is "unlocked". After that DDFSTRT works normally again in same scanline.

Both start and stop being active at the same (and stop having priority) would explain this side-effect fully.

[tonioni]

Like https://github.com/tonioni/WinUAE/issues/179, this is now solved and correctly emulated. Note that result is quite different on OCS vs ECS. DDFSTRT/STOP logic is "interesting" and there are lots of differences between OCS and ECS/AGA.