RootlessJamesDSP icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
RootlessJamesDSP copied to clipboard

Root version of the app does not work with Magisk 26.1

Open RishiPrasath opened this issue 1 year ago • 17 comments

This is the error message: Screenshot (Apr 19, 2023 3_35_17 PM)

I tried installing via the Huawei method and am still facing the issue. So please let me know how to troubleshoot. Thank you.

RishiPrasath avatar Apr 19 '23 07:04 RishiPrasath

The original JamesDSP app will crash too. The affected devices are : Xperia 1 IV Redmi Note 10 Pro (Both are installed with the latest stable Magisk)

RishiPrasath avatar Apr 19 '23 07:04 RishiPrasath

I am not facing this problem, and also using magisk 26.1.

But, beyond this, are you sure this is a problem of the app? Have you tried the original jamesdsp apk? If that is not working as well, it is a problem with the JDSP magisk module, and not this app.

coxackie avatar Apr 21 '23 11:04 coxackie

Yeah, it's the problem with the magisk module. I'm using v4.6 of the module.

RishiPrasath avatar Apr 21 '23 18:04 RishiPrasath

In fact how did you get it to work? Would be grateful if can you help, thanks .

RishiPrasath avatar Apr 22 '23 03:04 RishiPrasath

In fact how did you get it to work? Would be grateful if can you help, thanks .

Nothing really, just updated from 25 to 26.1 and everything continued to work.

coxackie avatar Apr 22 '23 09:04 coxackie

Ah, I see; that's what happened. But bad news, if you remove the app and magisk module and reinstall again, you will hit the issue. So I just wanted to let you know.

RishiPrasath avatar Apr 23 '23 17:04 RishiPrasath

Ah, I see; that's what happened. But bad news, if you remove the app and magisk module and reinstall again, you will hit the issue. So I just wanted to let you know.

ok, thanks for the heads up. I still do not think this issue belongs here. However, it does raise the question of whether @ThePBone would be interested in creating a full magisk module that installs the library plus his apk. I think that would be the best scenario, seeing how he is a lot more active.

coxackie avatar Apr 24 '23 20:04 coxackie

The official JDSP app bundled with the Magisk module has no error handling when libjamesdsp.so isn't found, so it just crashes. That's the same issue as the error screen posted above.

However, it does raise the question of whether ThePBone would be interested in creating a full magisk module that installs the library plus his apk

I don't have any clue how these modules are setup/maintained, so I probably won't create one myself. (I also don't know why this issue happens on some devices in the first place; until now I only knew about the 'Huawei' option being a possible workaround).

timschneeb avatar Apr 26 '23 09:04 timschneeb

Except that Huawei doesn't work anymore in Magisk 26

RishiPrasath avatar May 02 '23 16:05 RishiPrasath

It seems to also apply to A12 LineageOS on the LG v30

Melodycloudu avatar May 09 '23 21:05 Melodycloudu

Another person published a patched Magisk module which appears to fix this issue. It also bundles the root version of this app alongside the original JDSP app:

https://github.com/akavkl/JamesDSP-for-Android/releases

timschneeb avatar May 09 '23 21:05 timschneeb

I've tried it , but the app still crashes. The affected device is Sony Xperia 1 IV.

RishiPrasath avatar May 16 '23 12:05 RishiPrasath

I'm having the exact same problem. Got a Moto One 5g Ace. And I miss my James!

The akavkl patch didn't help at all.

FailSafeNow avatar May 20 '23 07:05 FailSafeNow

The thing is back then before Magisk 26 I was able to use the Huawei patch. For the akavkl patch , I'm not sure how to verify if it's actually installing the Huawei patch.

RishiPrasath avatar May 20 '23 12:05 RishiPrasath

Last resort is Magisk Delta. 25.2 based. Only way to get it to work. Latest Jamesdsp 4.7 won't work on Magisk 26.1.

RishiPrasath avatar May 26 '23 15:05 RishiPrasath

Zackptg5 had released a new version, and it seems to have fixed this issue. https://github.com/Zackptg5/JamesDSPManager

a0193143 avatar Apr 05 '24 16:04 a0193143

Zackptg5 had released a new version, and it seems to have fixed this issue. https://github.com/Zackptg5/JamesDSPManager

I was looking for more information. He didn't mention compatibility with the newer Magisk. How do you know he fixed the issue?

FailSafeNow avatar Apr 22 '24 17:04 FailSafeNow