thunderbird-android icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
thunderbird-android copied to clipboard

Recipient address suggestions / collect addresses

Open vitalif opened this issue 8 years ago • 23 comments

Hi! First of all thanks for an opensource email client for Android, I use it since my first Android phone. But I want to report an inconvenience: k9 is not suggesting recipient addresses from previous emails, only from the smartphone addressbook. I use IMAP accounts. Is it possible to implement some kind of suggestions? At least from the headers of previously seen emails...

vitalif avatar Jan 08 '16 10:01 vitalif

We should probably limit the suggestions to addresses you have previously sent a message to. Otherwise users that subscribe to mailing lists will be flooded with (useless) suggestions.

cketti avatar Jan 13 '16 07:01 cketti

Thank you! This is not yet implemented right? I'd like to be beta-tester for it!

dddns avatar May 13 '18 11:05 dddns

Every time this is mentioned, maintainers either close the ticket, mark it off-topic, or call it a duplicate. Please, someone, somewhere, implement this very simple request - and no, it has not been implement yet, not in any alpha, nor beta! :-)

bokkiedog avatar May 16 '18 06:05 bokkiedog

Agree :P I think the -dev's don't like the auto-complete! but it's probably the most used feature when sending emails, believe us.

dddns avatar May 16 '18 08:05 dddns

This is not a discussion forum. You're not adding any relevant information to this issue. Please use the mailing list if you feel the need to reiterate your need for this feature.

cketti avatar May 16 '18 11:05 cketti

I would find a feature like this very useful too.

cmallwitz avatar Apr 30 '19 16:04 cmallwitz

Is this feature on a roadmap?

ngortheone avatar Jul 03 '19 16:07 ngortheone

Hello,

Do we know if anyone is working on this feature?

All the best

avatar1024 avatar Jul 07 '19 16:07 avatar1024

I cannot believe nobody has worked on this yet. This is literally the only mail client I've ever used where this feature isn't available. Is this project now dead/dormant?

bokkiedog avatar Aug 22 '19 14:08 bokkiedog

@bokkiedog sorry, I understand your frustration. I use K9 myself as a daily driver and I miss this feature too. But this is open source. Nobody is working full-time on this, people are trying to do this for free in the spare time they have. It is not fair to accuse them that they have not had a chance to work on this yet. If you can contribute and help to add the feature - I am sure that maintainers will be happy to review your code and give reasonable comments. If you can support the project with money and sponsor the feature - that might work too (not sure if there is an established donation option, but if there is - I would pay a bit to get this)

ngortheone avatar Aug 22 '19 19:08 ngortheone

I know how Free Software works. I put my money where my mouth is: my company is the founder Gold Sponsor of Debian LTS, for example! But that developers have ignored a highly-demanded and very simple to implement feature request implies this project is indeed dead. Your response confirms that further.

If I can find another Android mail client that properly handles shared IMAP folders, I'd be grateful for the advice.

bokkiedog avatar Aug 22 '19 21:08 bokkiedog

I have not found anything open source that comes close to K9. There is plenty of proprietary stuff, but I am not the best person to advice on that.

ngortheone avatar Aug 22 '19 21:08 ngortheone

After years of waiting I got fed up as well. Other open source options i am currently testing are: FairEmail, InboxPager and p≡p.

optimdevel avatar Mar 04 '20 16:03 optimdevel

hey, please take action on this issue! I consider it to be a rather basic functionality for an e-mail client.

ghost avatar Jul 06 '20 08:07 ghost

+1

dddns avatar Jul 06 '20 09:07 dddns

They are much more interested to make footling changes to the user interface than to add this fundamental, basic user requirement that every single other mail client I have ever used supports out of the box.

bokkiedog avatar Jul 06 '20 10:07 bokkiedog

I have tried FairEmail and never looked back. :-)

optimdevel avatar Jul 06 '20 11:07 optimdevel

is there any progress on this? I would rate this as very convenient

ristein avatar Dec 08 '20 18:12 ristein

+1, its the only missing feature in K9, which is the most used.

dddns avatar Dec 08 '20 18:12 dddns

  1. Would K9 only parse through the (possibly limited) e-mail history stored on the phone or actually check the server (which I would prefer)?

  2. The history check shouldn't be limited to just the folder "send" but to emails that have actually been send independent on location, possibly to avoid folders on server not matching what's set up on the phone (personally have that fixed now but didnt before) or maybe recent folder changes/newly installed K9 though having a longer history on server already...

Axelfoley85 avatar Apr 04 '22 14:04 Axelfoley85

Hi There,

No pressure, but any news about this? Thanks in advanced,

dddns avatar Jun 12 '22 15:06 dddns

How feasible is this? We should do it as it's something I've heard a bit since K-9 joined Thunderbird.

ryanleesipes avatar Feb 07 '23 04:02 ryanleesipes

Hi,

+1, its the only missing feature in K9 ❤️

floviolleau avatar Apr 24 '24 10:04 floviolleau