tdesktop icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
tdesktop copied to clipboard

[Feature Request] Hide that separate call window

Open fcore117 opened this issue 5 years ago • 22 comments

Please allow permanently hiding that separate call window like it was before, very distracting and disrupts work.

Telegram 2.3.0

fcore117 avatar Aug 19 '20 17:08 fcore117

Try this? https://postimg.cc/1V1mHJS4

VaGNaroK avatar Aug 22 '20 18:08 VaGNaroK

Try this? https://postimg.cc/1V1mHJS4

Sorry but i do not mean this but i want to hide call main window completley and only keep chat window with small call bar on top of it.

Want call only be here like it was before 2.3 old_way

Ghost tray when minimizing, bug? tray

Close that without closing a call. close

fcore117 avatar Aug 24 '20 13:08 fcore117

I'm having the same annoiyng UI bug. Telegram 2.3.1, Windows 10 Pro.

tormit avatar Aug 25 '20 18:08 tormit

old interface looks better

KES777 avatar Sep 18 '20 15:09 KES777

Reverted back to good working 2.2 and using until i can close window without closing call.

fcore117 avatar Sep 23 '20 23:09 fcore117

Latest Telegram 2.4.1 and still cannot get rid of that separate window, again i have to revert to older that have no separate window when calling. Very distracting.

fcore117 avatar Oct 02 '20 11:10 fcore117

@fcore117 Why not simply minimize it? 🤔

john-preston avatar Oct 02 '20 12:10 john-preston

@fcore117 Why not simply minimize it? 🤔

I need only Telegram main window when in conversation just like older ones and call status is running on top of Telegram itself, i exchange files and stuff in telegram and i do not need second useless window there. I reverted to older already and waiting until option or fix will arrive.

fcore117 avatar Oct 02 '20 12:10 fcore117

@fcore117 I don't understand why you can't minimize the "second useless window", it will minimize to taskbar and you will "exchange files and stuff in telegram", like before.

john-preston avatar Oct 02 '20 12:10 john-preston

Problem is not the window itself, but the ghost tray slot. It just taking up useful tray space and is really disturbing work. Also, when you accidentaly close it, call is canceled.

tormit avatar Oct 02 '20 13:10 tormit

@john-preston Why you should spent time to create useless second window and why users also should spent time to minimize it? Also, as noticed by others, this second useless window makes useless noise by taking space in status bar.

Also this second useless window has poor design in compare how call is made in old version. Even more the useless window with poor design has no photo of user which I am calling. I <3 when calling window have photo

KES777 avatar Oct 03 '20 10:10 KES777

+1. This pointless separate call window is making me crazy, please take time to remove this or atleast make it optional if someone should for some (weird) reason really like it.

Thanks! I really hope you can make it the simple way it used to be.

Serverkill avatar Oct 08 '20 21:10 Serverkill

The second window makes alt-tabbing to Telegram more tedious, as well as navigating to it with Meta+Number. I get why it's useful for video calls, but allowing it to be closed and hidden in the program without ending the call (like the old window used to work), would still allow for that functionality without sacrificing user experience.

Noammac avatar Nov 06 '20 19:11 Noammac

There are second group of users too who use Telegram for hours on gaming or for basic calls and continue using other things same time but constantly hit that horrible window and close it and then call closes too. It should stay within Telegram window itself. Telegram is best of every IM app for every purpose, from work to gaming and even in industry as it is secure, comfortable and helluva fast thanks to C++

PS: If someone here wants to revert back to 2.2 then download 2.2, disconnect internet, launch telegram and disable updates then connect internet again and start using until fix comes. If you need video then sadly you have to endure secondary window.

Best solution would me move both Video and Audio to user chat window so it is one piece again.

fcore117 avatar Nov 08 '20 17:11 fcore117

Anyone knows is 2.5.1 fixed that secondary ghost window hiding problem without call closing? Changelog talks about improvements but i am not sure.

fcore117 avatar Dec 25 '20 12:12 fcore117

Anyone knows is 2.5.1 fixed that secondary ghost window hiding problem without call closing?

Not for 1-to-1 calls. For voice chats, on the other hand, you can close it without disconnecting from the voice chat

RememberTheAir avatar Dec 25 '20 12:12 RememberTheAir

Anyone knows is 2.5.1 fixed that secondary ghost window hiding problem without call closing?

Not for 1-to-1 calls. For voice chats, on the other hand, you can close it without disconnecting from the voice chat

Thanks for info, waiting until fix arrives and then i can finally upgrade too and keep voice conferencing and working without this distracting secondary window.

fcore117 avatar Dec 25 '20 13:12 fcore117

Problem is not the window itself, but the ghost tray slot. It just taking up useful tray space and is really disturbing work. Also, when you accidentaly close it, call is canceled.

Yeah, that's really annoying. I keep accidentally closing the call because its expected to be able to close the window, and only closing the call when clicking on hang up button.

Helderjfl avatar Jul 18 '21 02:07 Helderjfl

It's been two years since this feature request was opened! Why hasn't it been addressed? As paying users of the premium service, we'd appreciate a response from the developers, something that makes us feel like progress is being made, at the very least. While I acknowledge the various aesthetic updates and features implemented during this time, this particular request is a quality-of-life improvement that requires immediate attention!

Lordvader81 avatar Jan 30 '24 15:01 Lordvader81

Progress should not made against people like this horrible call window. Same thing is with disabling Stories especially in phones. In short, please do not plan any more annoying features and-OR give option instantly with together with feature to disable it. Avoid excessive bloating up Telegram as it is only sane C++ communication tool left in world where lazy programmers make Nodejs and Electron bloat apps everywhere. Pretty please for disable option, and still thanks to all because of being written right way.

fcore117 avatar Feb 02 '24 10:02 fcore117

No comments from the devs ??????????????

Lordvader81 avatar Feb 02 '24 13:02 Lordvader81

I can't believe this is still an issue, in 2024. Who likes extra window just for fun?? I've lost count how many times I have clicked that useless window when I want to write something to chat while in call.

Serverkill avatar Feb 16 '24 09:02 Serverkill

Feel free to test v4.15.3.

23rd avatar Mar 13 '24 22:03 23rd

Feel free to test v4.15.3.

Changelog do not mention hiding call window like it was old times? hidden feature? Edit: seems working after test.... finally some sense.

fcore117 avatar Mar 15 '24 16:03 fcore117

Finally!

tormit avatar Mar 26 '24 18:03 tormit