cd icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
cd copied to clipboard

Property:status

Open mtrekels opened this issue 5 years ago • 10 comments

Label Status
Definition The development status of the collection during a specified period.
Usage
Existing property
Existing class
Existing property identifier
Format Text
Required Yes
Repeatable No
Constraints
Examples Complete, In part, Developing, Closed, Active growth, Consumable, Decreasing, Lost, Missing, Passive growth, Static
Notes The values/vocabularies for a status are predicated by the statusType. The in the examples mentioned terms are a cumulative list of terms associated with several different statusTypes.

mtrekels avatar Nov 26 '19 12:11 mtrekels

Not 100% clear whether https://terms.tdwg.org/wiki/Natural_Collections_Description#Development_Status_Type or https://terms.tdwg.org/wiki/Natural_Collections_Description#Conservation_Status_Type is addressed I understood conservation Status in the first place

Format: text

szucsichnikolaus avatar Feb 11 '20 11:02 szucsichnikolaus

This similar to Stev's comment elsewhere about more literal term labels. Development status is the intent for this field. Conservation status therefore would be a separate term.

rondlg avatar Feb 11 '20 15:02 rondlg

So shall we prepend 'development' in front of 'Status' for each of the properties in the CollectionHistory class?

mswoodburn avatar Mar 15 '20 19:03 mswoodburn

This class is about the history of the collection not its development nor conservation.

qgroom avatar Mar 27 '20 16:03 qgroom

Therefore, it should details events, such as founded, destroyed, split, merged etc

qgroom avatar Mar 27 '20 16:03 qgroom

I'm looking for a home for GBIF's "accession_status", and if merged (see last week's discussion) in consequence also for GBIF's "personal_collection". CollectionHistory seems to be the fitting class.

GBIF's "accession_status" has the vocabulary ['Institutional', 'Project']. After merging with "personal_collection" this might form the expanded vocabulary ['Institutional', 'Project', 'Personal"].

Should this fit with @qgroom 's type of vocabulary ['accessioned', 'destroyed', 'bought', 'sold', 'split', 'distributed', ...] "status" will be the property. Otherwise, maybe 2+ properties are needed, since legal, management and practical (access) considerations seem to get intermingled.

Descriptions of the status of a collection's history involve information otherwise associated with Institutions (Governance /Funding: institutional (=accessioned) vs. private), PersonRole (Owner), and prov:Activity (transactions: buying, selling, destroying, distributing).

Edit: also GBIF's "active" property with ['inactive', 'active'] seems to map somewhere here.

jbstatgen avatar Feb 15 '22 17:02 jbstatgen

This sounds as if LC's Event is more in line with ABCD's Dataset(s). I don't know, but that sounds unlikely. An event has a specific time and place, I wouldn't not have thought a dataset would.

However, with properties "samplingProtocol" and "habitat", those sounded to me more like ABCD's Unit/Gathering/Method: > "The method (including technical means) used to make the collection or observation or to describe the capture event." and Unit/Gathering/Biotope: "An element for citing biotope type terms (e.g. classification terms) and measurements (e.g. vegetation height, salinity, slope) related to the unit's gathering site". Sounds reasonable

Does a mapping exist between abcd:Unit/Gathering and dwc term(s)? I don't know. It would be best to ask someone from Berlin Botanic Garden, maybe @DavidFichtmueller

qgroom avatar Feb 15 '22 18:02 qgroom

@qgroom 's above comment needs to be moved to the Event issue, https://github.com/tdwg/cd/issues/362

jbstatgen avatar Feb 17 '22 15:02 jbstatgen

To clarify the examples here, we need to make them hierarchical with corresponding statusType values -- e.g.

  • statusType = Organizational

    • status = open
  • statusType = Organizational

    • status = closed

magpiedin avatar Mar 10 '22 15:03 magpiedin

This is now implemented as a 2-level hierarchy. -- For including status at the Institutional level then you would attach an ObjectGroup to the institution and then this CollectionStatusHistory attaches to that,

rondlg avatar Mar 17 '22 15:03 rondlg