proposal-binary-ast icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
proposal-binary-ast copied to clipboard

What is the current status of this proposal?

Open Becavalier opened this issue 5 years ago • 13 comments
trafficstars

As titled.

Is there any progress on this proposal?

Becavalier avatar Sep 24 '20 10:09 Becavalier

I can't speak for the proposal's champions but Cloudflare experimented with distributing binary AST instead of JavaScript for compatible eyeballs. We are planning to continue to work on the proposal.

xtuc avatar Sep 28 '20 10:09 xtuc

Where can I read more about the Cloudflare experimentation?

Zizzamia avatar Oct 03 '20 21:10 Zizzamia

We wrote a blog post https://blog.cloudflare.com/binary-ast/.

xtuc avatar Oct 03 '20 21:10 xtuc

This is super interesting! Could binary AST being stored by the Service Worker in the Cache Storage as we do with JS files? I'm def going to experiment a bit with this proposal, now that I see Cloudflare is investing on it. 😁

Zizzamia avatar Oct 04 '20 02:10 Zizzamia

I saw @syg is one of the champions. May I know is there anything blocking the advancing of this proposal?

Becavalier avatar Oct 09 '20 15:10 Becavalier

ping it

lygstate avatar Feb 04 '21 06:02 lygstate

Is there interest from Chrome to implement this?

akhiljay avatar Jul 05 '21 14:07 akhiljay

So, what is the current status of this proposal? This looks abandoned. uh.... I am not good in English, please forgive me if I offended.

lihugang avatar Jan 09 '23 14:01 lihugang

No one is working on it for the last several years

vdjeric avatar Jan 09 '23 21:01 vdjeric

@vdjeric Probably would be worth to archive the repo (for whoever has the rights to do so) to avoid confusion.

RReverser avatar Jan 09 '23 21:01 RReverser

Proposals often have no work done on them for years, and then champions pick them back up, so inactivity can't be used as a sign of withdrawal.

If the champions (which include @vdjeric and @RReverser, as well as @syg and @Yoric) wish to withdraw the proposal, or step down as champions of it, they'd need to decide that collectively and individually, respectively. Once withdrawn, it would certainly be archived.

ljharb avatar Jan 09 '23 22:01 ljharb

Ah, fair enough.

RReverser avatar Jan 09 '23 23:01 RReverser