tailscale-qpkg
tailscale-qpkg copied to clipboard
tailscale
After upgrade to QTS > 5.0.1.2145 Tailscale is not compatible anymore
I just upgraded to the latest firmware from Qnap, 5.0.1.2145. Unfortunately, tailscale (latest version 1.30.2) is not compatible anymore with it. :-(
Can you elaborate? Doesn't start anymore?
What is the output of
./tailscaled --port 41641 --state=var/lib/tailscale/tailscaled.state --socket=var/run/tailscale/tailscaled.sock
I have the same issue. It is broken.
That command works and eventually the service comes up but it dies after I Ctrl-C the process in the CLI.
However, when I go to do some thing like:
[/share/CACHEDEV1_DATA/.qpkg/Tailscale] # ./tailscale -socket var/run/tailscale/tailscaled.sock status
failed to connect to local tailscaled; it doesn't appear to be running (sudo systemctl start tailscaled ?)
It appears that the service no longer works/starts on this version of QTS.
So, the way Tailscale works is that the command tailscaled runs a background daemon which does the tunneling etc. The command tailscale (note without "d" in the end) is the frontend for configuring the daemon at runtime and querying status etc.
So, you would have to run the commands in parallel -- first start up tailscaled and if it has started without errors, run tailscale in second terminal. If you do it this way, are there some signs of the problems in the logs?
Usually, when everything works normally, this package starts tailscaled command in the background and the user has only to use tailscale. But if there are problems, we do not see the logs from the tailscaled, thats why I recommended running it from command line.
I'll check also Tailscale issues list to see some regression. In that regard -- does it work with latest QTS version + previous Tailscale version (1.28 for example?). My QNAP is other side of the continent and I get physical access to it once a year, so I really wouldn't to lose connectivity :/
Problem solved!
https://github.com/tailscale/tailscale/issues/5673#issuecomment-1250206427
@ivokub Be carful updating remotely...
Problem solved!
https://github.com/tailscale/tailscale/issues/5673#issuecomment-1250206427
@ivokub Be carful updating remotely...
Thanks! Great that you got it solved.
Yeah, if there is no way to set the flag before updating firmware, then I really cannot upgrade. Quite annoying, to be honest.
I'll keep the issue open and will add a note in the readme.
I'm sorry,
it's not the digital signature.I set the flag already.
Unfortunately the screenshot is in German. but it's says nohting else than tailscale is not compatible with QTS 5.0.1 and please donwgrade.
cheers
What architecture of the package are you running? x86, ARM?
I'm having a TS-453B, it's x86 64 Bit
Hmm, very strange. I'll see maybe QPKG packaging has changed and can have a quick fix.
ZeroTier has similar errors: https://discuss.zerotier.com/t/qnap-failed-to-install-zerotier-downgrade-qts-to-5-0-0-or-an-older-compatible-version/9346, so I guess it is wider problem with QNAP.
Just in case - do you have QVPN package installed? Can you try installing it first and then reinstall latest Tailscale?
And FYI for anyone reading -- the latest Tailscale package is built with the latest version of QDK kit. CI always fetches the default QDK from source and uses it for building the QPKG package. So the issue shouldn't at least be that the package is built with old tools.
ZeroTier has similar errors: https://discuss.zerotier.com/t/qnap-failed-to-install-zerotier-downgrade-qts-to-5-0-0-or-an-older-compatible-version/9346, so I guess it is wider problem with QNAP.
Just in case - do you have QVPN package installed? Can you try installing it first and then reinstall latest Tailscale?
I do have QVPN installed already. Can't install tailscale, same error: not compatible.
I'm running 1.30.1 and its still working on my TVS-471. Can you try that build?
Hi wingcomm,
do you have the latest firmware 5.0.1? Everything worked fine until QTS 5.0.0.2131 build 20220815 Don't upgrade, otherwise tailscale (any version) won't work. Cheers
I'm running QTS 5.0.1.2145 on my TVS-471 and Tailscale 1.30.1 right now...how did I dodge this bullet?
I will add that I'm a tad afraid to upgrade to 1.30.2 until this issue is resolved. 😬
I uninstalled tailscale, since when not even able to install it :-( I just tried it again with 1.30.1, without success. :-(
Meanwhile try to workaround with a docker image. For the future, @ŧailscale I think they need to get a digital signature anyhow. As already stated in the Release Notes. By default always switched off
I also had the same issue and the only current solution i found was to downgrade to 5.0.0 version from Aug 2022, then i could upgrade from 1.26 to 1.30.2 not even 1.26 was running on 5.0.1 release
@ivokub : I was opening a ticket at Qnap and they were so kind to invite me to a discord channel for discussing the issue. Perhaps you or somebody from tailscale could join ? https://discord.com/invite/H2QaRJE72q
thanks
@ivokub : I was opening a ticket at Qnap and they were so kind to invite me to a discord channel for discussing the issue. Perhaps you or somebody from tailscale could join ? https://discord.com/invite/H2QaRJE72q
thanks
I looked around Discord. Is there a particular channel or user which was referred?
@ivokub : I was opening a ticket at Qnap and they were so kind to invite me to a discord channel for discussing the issue. Perhaps you or somebody from tailscale could join ? https://discord.com/invite/H2QaRJE72q thanks
I looked around Discord. Is there a particular channel or user which was referred?
Hi Ivo, I was looking around, seem no special topic, seems we would be able to start a discussion there.
Fwiw, installing the latest QVPN app, then reinstalling Tailscale 1.30.2 (and reconnecting via the commands in the Readme here) worked for me.
Fwiw, installing the latest QVPN app, then reinstalling Tailscale 1.30.2 (and reconnecting via the commands in the Readme here) worked for me.
Hi Case. I do have QVPN 3.0.779. I tried following:
- QVPN stop, Tailscale install --> failure
- Deinstalled QVPN, Tailscale install --> failure
- Reinstalled QVPN, Tailscale install --> failure Sorry, didn't work for me. Currently I do not have tailsacle installed at all, as it does not allow in anymore :-(
@ivokub : I was opening a ticket at Qnap and they were so kind to invite me to a discord channel for discussing the issue. Perhaps you or somebody from tailscale could join ? https://discord.com/invite/H2QaRJE72q thanks
I looked around Discord. Is there a particular channel or user which was referred?
Hi Ivo, I was looking around, seem no special topic, seems we would be able to start a discussion there.
I tried asking but received no reply. Will try further.
I initially installed Tailscale 1.26 under QTS 5.0.0 then, still under QTS 5.0.0, I updated it to Tailscale 1.30.1. Tailscale 1.30.1 is still running properly after upgrading from QTS 5.0.0 to QTS 5.0.1.2145.
Having Tailscale functional on this specific NAS isn't critical to me. If I can help with testing anything please let me know.
Edit: I do not have and have never had QVPN installed.
hi all, I have the problem for that I cannot click open !! even I restart NAS and also re-install 1.30.2 still cannot click "open"
condition NAS TS-364 tailscale VPN : 1.30.2 OS: QTS 5.0.0.2131
Just for Info, upgraded to firmware QTS 5.0.1.2173. Still the same issue
Upgraded to firmware QTS 5.0.1.2173 and Tailscale 1.30.1 continued to work properly.
Upgraded Tailscale to v1.30.2 using QNap Club package and upgrade was successful. Rebooted to make certain Tailscale would continue to run properly.
In case it's helpful, here's the Tailscale section from qpkg.conf
[Tailscale] Name = Tailscale Class = null Status = complete store = fdb515956e895c7b287c5075b73b9b90 Build = 20220930 Display_Name = Tailscale VPN Version = 1.30.2 Author = Qoolbox QPKG_File = Tailscale.qpkg Date = 2022-10-04 Shell = /share/CACHEDEV1_DATA/.qpkg/Tailscale/Tailscale.sh Volume_Select = 3 Install_Path = /share/CACHEDEV1_DATA/.qpkg/Tailscale RC_Number = 122 Enable = TRUE FW_Ver_Min = 4.2.6