Cancelling payment sheet with custom flow doesn't send error, if customer has saved cards

[ehaycox]

Describe the bug If you create a payment sheet with custom flow, and initialize it with a customer that has stripe cards, the payment sheet selects a card by default. This means if you cancel out of the payment sheet, the card is already selected, so it doesn't throw a Cancelled error, it counts it as having selected a payment method.

I think this relates to: https://github.com/stripe/stripe-react-native/pull/975

To Reproduce Steps to reproduce the behavior:

1. Create payment sheet with custom flow
2. When call initPaymentSheet, fill in stripe customer and ephemeral key for a stripe customer that has saved cards.
3. Open the payment sheet, a card should be selected by default
4. Click the cross on the payment sheet, but presentPaymentSheet returns a null error, and non-null paymentOption with default card.

Expected behavior Should return a cancel error, or at least a null paymentOption

Smartphone (please complete the following information):

• Android: OnePlus Nord / OS: 11
• IOS: IPhone 11 / IOS: 16.5

[remonh87]

I was fixing an issue in our flutter repo and I can confirm above scenario.

Furthermore there is an inconsistency in propagating result objects between android and iOS. For the following scenario:

1. init payment sheet and after that use present payment sheet (no user so it will only show the Apple Pay or google pay option )
2. When choosing select payment method press cancel.
3. Behaviour android: it provides an error with cancelled. Behaviour iOS : it defaults to the Apple Pay payment option and we can continue.

[ChurikiTenna]

1+

When will this be fixed??

[paul-testec]

any update bro?

[rjsrikureja]

can we get an update on this?

[marlene89]

+1 getting same issue. When using custom flow, pressing out of the payment sheet or clicking on X button to close it, returns selected default payment option and does not throw any error.

[amin79]

any update?

[Resource-4]

Facing the same issue in react-native stripe sdk, any update on this? or any work around for this?

[rjsrikureja]

I had to switch from custom flow due to this error. I recommend other people do the same if it’s possible in your design.