notesnook icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
notesnook copied to clipboard

Is this app Code Signed?

Open dtantono opened this issue 1 year ago • 4 comments

What happened?

When I installed a Windows client, the Windows Smart Screen popup appears. Is the Windows client code signed?

Steps to reproduce the problem

  1. Double click the app
  2. Windows Smart Screen popup appears

Version

2.1.2

Platform/OS

Windows

Relevant log output

No response

dtantono avatar Jul 24 '22 02:07 dtantono

At this point, we cannot afford a code signing certificate ($400/yr - $600/yr). Perhaps another option is delivering the app via Microsoft Store.

thecodrr avatar Jul 24 '22 13:07 thecodrr

Just so you know. That's almost a reason for me not to install the app. Especially in an enterprise environment. I specifically came here to see why the code isn't signed. Now i might reconsider installing it and getting a pro subscription to help you out with your certificate. ;)

cnoize35 avatar Sep 08 '22 08:09 cnoize35

@cnoize35 if it is preventing you to install the app, you can just use the web app for the time being.

thecodrr avatar Sep 08 '22 08:09 thecodrr

Everything is ok. I have installed it by now and I'm loving it btw. All I wanted to say is that you may lose out on a couple of users as long as this message appears during the installation. dontrun People might get a little scared by this message and wonder why their PC had to be protected from your software. It's also not very clear that you have to click on "more info" to be able to install it anyway.

cnoize35 avatar Sep 09 '22 16:09 cnoize35

EV code signing cert isn't strictly necessary for suppression of SmartScreen prompts. When using an OV cert, Microsoft will eventually suppress the prompt based on reputation heuristics. This could reduce cost to somewhere in the realm of 120 USD/yr.

Getting any signing, even with an OV certificate, would help increase assurance that the binary hasn't been modified after you build it. I'd love to see this happen. It's my one complaint with the product.

protocolist avatar Nov 10 '23 09:11 protocolist