udisks icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
udisks copied to clipboard

looks like encrypted tcrypt devices or partitions are not inheriting the removable flag correctly.

Open f1-outsourcing opened this issue 2 years ago • 0 comments

After

touch /etc/udisks2/tcrypt.conf

tcrypt encrypted partitions/devices on usb pen drives seem to always get removable=0

I get the impression the removable is like the rotational and there is not a direct relationship with services on the device, or at least there should not be. I read some stuff that sometimes drivers incorrectly set this, so it could be someone just forgot to implement this properly.

I noticed also that eg. the removable is not directly available on partitions, so it would be more logical to not even have this listed here at all. It could also be that it is required/expected/default of the kernel for such devices residing in the /dev/ root. I think the the dm created by udisks should set this flag correctly.

these are the crypt devices that should have the removable=1

lsblk --output NAME,KNAME,TYPE,SIZE,MOUNTPOINT
sda                 sda       disk   28.7G 
├─sda1              sda1      part      1G /run/media/xxx/xxxxxxxxxxx
├─sda2              sda2      part   26.3G /run/media/xxx/xxxxxxxxxxxxx
└─sda3              sda3      part    1.3G 
  └─tcrypt-2051_2   dm-0      crypt   1.3G 
    └─tcrypt-2051_1 dm-1      crypt   1.3G 
      └─tcrypt-2051 dm-2      crypt   1.3G /run/media/xxx/xxxxxxxxxxxxxx

f1-outsourcing avatar Mar 13 '23 16:03 f1-outsourcing