temporary-containers
temporary-containers copied to clipboard
stoically
(Firefox) Two tabs open and then one tab closes almost instantly
When I open Firefox, two tabs open and then one tab closes almost instantly (leaving me with one tab/window open as expected). I've narrowed down the problem by disabling all other add-ons and the problem only occurs when temporary containers is enabled. When I disable temporary containers the problem doesn't occur. Your help would be much appreciated! Thanks for your good work!!!
Here's a list of my existing add-ons: uBlock Origin Local cdn Clear URLs Cookie Auto Delete PopUpOFF Multi Account Containers Skip Redirect Smart Referrer Facebook container Tampermonkey
- Temporary Containers Version: 1.9.2
- Firefox Version: 92
Actual behavior
opens 2 tabs at Firefox startup (then closes one almost instantly)
Expected behavior
Open just one tab
it seems to appear
- when you open a link in new tab that belongs to a different container than that of the parent tab.
- when you create a new, containerless tab using Ctrl-T and opening any URL
@stoically would you be so kind as to provide your input?
adding screen recordings to help better visualize the issue
https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/10742312/138750234-e0a1003c-d246-4141-a816-ee4ec0c61120.mp4
https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/10742312/138750261-b3b630e4-998e-40bd-b028-d2353994d907.mp4
Hello, I hope that you're doing well today. The issue only occurs when Stoically/temporary-containers is enabled. When I disable Stoically temporary-containers the issue goes away. My file was too big so I added a link in Imgur. Thank you! I know you must be busy!
https://imgur.com/bX7s9A3
I've also noticed this issue on browser/new tab load. Often just a visual glitch, but if there's some load on your computer the tab might be destroyed and replaced mid typing.
but if there's some load on your computer the tab might be destroyed and replaced mid typing.
yes the visual aspect is whatever, but this is the real problem
I've noticed this too. Firefox 94.0.1 with Temporary Containers v1.9.2. It's been going on for a while, so it doesn't appear to be a recent regression.
Does this happen with "Advanced Automatic Mode" configured to "Don't reopen instantly" or do you have "Blank page" configured as Firefox homepage? If so, then two tabs and one closing is expected behavior, as that's how TC needs to do it. There's no API to convert an existing tab from no container to temporary container.
I've had this happen recently too. I'll end up with about 50 random temporary containers in my list that stick around (I have use history deletes instead of temporary by default and have it set to delete immediately after the last tab in it closes).
My homepage is configured as an addon (Tabby Cats, to be exact).
There's no API to convert an existing tab from no container to temporary container.
Looking at the Automatic Mode options it's pretty cut and dry. Hopefully a fix/workaround is available one day; otherwise it's a minor annoyance to deal with this limitation.
@pixiekat
I'll end up with about 50 random temporary containers in my list that stick around (I have use history deletes instead of temporary by default and have it set to delete immediately after the last tab in it closes).
That sounds more like #371
@fefo-dev
Hopefully a fix/workaround is available one day; otherwise it's a minor annoyance to deal with this limitation.
It's a long-standing feature request: https://github.com/mozilla/multi-account-containers/issues/1029 - and given that containers seem to have no priority for firefox at the moment and the task in itself is huge, I'm not hopeful that it'll be available anytime soon.
Does this happen with "Advanced Automatic Mode" configured to "Don't reopen instantly" or do you have "Blank page" configured as Firefox homepage? If so, then two tabs and one closing is expected behavior, as that's how TC needs to do it. There's no API to convert an existing tab from no container to temporary container.
In General, I have Automatic Mode selected and in Advanced I have Instantly reopen new tabs in [TCs] selected.
For the Firefox home page, I have a moz-extension: URL that loads the page of another extension.
For the Firefox home page, I have a moz-extension: URL that loads the page of another extension.
In that case it's expected behavior. If the flickering is now more visible than in the past, then maybe something in firefox changed in terms of how fast tabs close/open.
For the Firefox home page, I have a moz-extension: URL that loads the page of another extension.
In that case it's expected behavior. If the flickering is now more visible than in the past, then maybe something in firefox changed in terms of how fast tabs close/open.
Thanks for the details. And if I change the home page to a moz-extension: URL to use a bookmark with the same URL or "Use current pages" (with just that moz-extension: URL opened), or other such trickery, would anything change? I'm thinking not, as I'm guessing the issue is that moz-extension: URLs are protected by the Firefox by default.