ideas icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
ideas copied to clipboard

Hierarchical Taxonomies

Open jasonvarga opened this issue 6 years ago • 28 comments

As explained in statamic/cms#74

jasonvarga avatar Aug 12 '19 20:08 jasonvarga

+1, definitely need this.

geekish avatar Apr 03 '20 15:04 geekish

I just ran into this problem.

stuartcusackie avatar Jul 21 '20 15:07 stuartcusackie

+1. Hope to to see this soon

tobinski avatar Feb 24 '21 14:02 tobinski

@stuartcusackie and @tobinski could you please click the 👍 icon above to vote for the feature. I'm not sure if they can count the +1 in texts automatically.

marcorieser avatar Oct 28 '21 15:10 marcorieser

@stuartcusackie and @tobinski could you please click the 👍 icon above to vote for the feature. I'm not sure if they can count the +1 in texts automatically.

done.

stuartcusackie avatar Oct 28 '21 15:10 stuartcusackie

Why ist this still not implemented? Definitely need this!

pathly-dev avatar Feb 09 '22 11:02 pathly-dev

Because of all the other things people also need that we have been implementing. We’ll get to it as soon as we can!

jackmcdade avatar Feb 09 '22 12:02 jackmcdade

@jackmcdade sorry if that sounded like that, but this wasn't supposed to sound like an attack to the statamic devs. Just wanted to push this issue, since it's already 3 years old 😅

pathly-dev avatar Feb 09 '22 12:02 pathly-dev

It's a really really big feature... 😅

jackmcdade avatar Feb 09 '22 13:02 jackmcdade

This feature is one of the deciding factors when we are starting new projects, when we ask ourselves which CMS will suit the job, anything that needs multiple layers of taxonomies for even moderately complex search/filtering, we need to look at other options. I'm looking forward to when taxonomies are overhauled a little bit so we can use Statamic for that niche of projects as well. :)

sliver37 avatar Feb 10 '22 06:02 sliver37

This feature is one of the deciding factors when we are starting new projects, when we ask ourselves which CMS will suit the job, anything that needs multiple layers of taxonomies for even moderately complex search/filtering, we need to look at other options. I'm looking forward to when taxonomies are overhauled a little bit so we can use Statamic for that niche of projects as well. :)

Exactly this 😅

marcorieser avatar Feb 10 '22 08:02 marcorieser

Would be a really nice feature to have!

kobe-f8 avatar Apr 12 '22 11:04 kobe-f8

Just chiming in to say that this is something I, too, would like to see being prioritized.

prikkprikkprikk avatar Apr 17 '22 09:04 prikkprikkprikk

Right now we are having a discussion with a client that needs hierarchical taxonomies.

arlindmusliu avatar Apr 21 '22 12:04 arlindmusliu

Please add a 👍 reaction instead of adding comments - that way the Team can sort the feature requests by the 👍 reaction.

duncanmcclean avatar Apr 21 '22 12:04 duncanmcclean

What is the status on this? I understand it is a big job, but almost ANY site with a category use-case, will have a need for nested categories.

ExpDev07 avatar May 31 '22 17:05 ExpDev07

I don't believe it's being worked on yet.

Based on the number of 👍 I'm guessing it's somewhere high up on the Roadmap but unsure on the ETA.

duncanmcclean avatar May 31 '22 17:05 duncanmcclean

Am also among the hordes of people awaiting this feature, would be great to get some sort of ETA for those weighing up starting new projects if possible. thanks!

https://github.com/statamic/cms/discussions?discussions_q=nested

samburgers avatar Jun 22 '22 02:06 samburgers

I'd love to see this happen! The sooner the better 🙏

espenlg avatar Jun 24 '22 08:06 espenlg

+1, this is a must have! Hard to tell client to move from WP without this feature.

P4KM4N avatar Jun 28 '22 18:06 P4KM4N

Is there a sponsorship program to get features like this implemented? Im already a paying pro user, but i would definitely be interested in sponsoring crucial things like this to get worked on

samburgers avatar Jul 18 '22 22:07 samburgers

Now is the time to join the discussion here: https://github.com/statamic/ideas/issues/839

marcorieser avatar Aug 15 '22 06:08 marcorieser

This was a blocking feature for me unfortunately. Hierarchical tags / more robust ontology is important for so many projects.

https://www.npmjs.com/package/sanity-plugin-taxonomy-manager

braco avatar Feb 09 '23 03:02 braco

Statamic can't really move far beyond tiny simple small business websites without massive cludge work till this is a thing. We've built big sites on it, but it's a huge time-sinking headache and makes us think twice about using this CMS for anything serious, really. For simple small business websites, we'd probably stick with WordPress. This issue is holding Statamic back, big time.

hmw-anthonyc avatar Mar 09 '23 23:03 hmw-anthonyc

@hmw-anthonyc Thanks for the feedback.

jackmcdade avatar Mar 09 '23 23:03 jackmcdade

I've been watching the development of Statamic from the sidelines for a little while, thinking about how it might replace Drupal in my tech stack. In most ways, Statamic is far superior to Drupal (speed, content structure, restful interface, content authoring experience etc...) Hierarchal Taxonomies are really the only missing feature that's a road block. I've experimented using Navigation and various field types to see if I could develop a workaround, but to no avail. I'd love to see this feature added in a future version. (Or I'd love to contribute my time as a dev to help make it happen :-)

quadradan avatar Oct 19 '23 19:10 quadradan

@quadradan you can use a structured collection and an entries field for this use case. You lose magic routing but its otherwise pretty much the same.

ryanmitchell avatar Oct 23 '23 16:10 ryanmitchell