provisions-data icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
provisions-data copied to clipboard

Unresolved Allocation Issue for Starknet Users

Open mathaszip opened this issue 1 year ago • 27 comments

Dear Starknet Team,

I hope this message finds you well. I am writing to bring attention to a concerning issue regarding allocations for Starknet users, as outlined in the provisions page.

Several users, myself included, have diligently met all the criteria specified on the provisions page but have not received the expected allocation. This situation has left the community feeling disheartened, as we fulfilled all the requirements yet received no compensation.

Attempts to address this matter on Discord have resulted in what appears to be automated responses, indicating potential oversight of criteria. However, I can assure you that I and others have thoroughly met all stipulated conditions. It has come to my attention that the filtering process during sybil filtering might be a cause for this discrepancy.

While I understand the necessity of such measures, I find it perplexing in my case, as I maintain only a single Starknet account. This should theoretically render my account immune to being filtered out. Having been a Starknet member since May and actively utilizing the platform throughout 2023 and to the present date, I find it disheartening to be excluded from the allocation despite meeting all criteria.

Although I cannot speak for the entire community regarding multiple wallets, I sincerely hope that this matter can be promptly investigated and resolved. For your reference, my eligible wallet is:

0x04e0113fB6502022D9E7838E788DC0a0B7E2407Eade744E80306Eb269F603d7d

I want to emphasize that my intention is not to express anger, but rather frustration. I trust that you understand the disappointment of meeting all criteria and not receiving the expected allocation. I kindly request your assistance in addressing and resolving this issue promptly.

Thank you for your attention to this matter, and I hope for a swift resolution.

Sincerely,

Mathias


Before commenting your wallet address, please check if your wallet should have been eligible using this dashboard!

If your wallet meets the following criteria you should have been given an allocation:

  • Active Months > 3
  • ETH Balance (15th of November 2023) > 0.005 ETH
  • Cumulative TX Volume > $100
  • Transactions > 5

Here is an example of my wallet that met all the criteria: 7ada15eeeb98e315f4762c6fd659aca0

Thank you in advance!


UPDATE 20/02/2024

On the Starknet Discord server, several Starknet team members announced an upcoming second round of provisions, which is certainly welcome news. However, amidst this anticipation, questions linger: will those of us excluded from the initial airdrop receive our allocation in subsequent rounds? It's disheartening that a corporation of such magnitude resorts to repetitive, impersonal communication rather than crafting bespoke messages. This ongoing situation is exhausting. Acknowledge the missteps in sybil filtering, take responsibility, and rectify the error and reward us, the users who met all criteria, but received nothing.

This right here is the exact message that I am referring to: Skærmbillede 2024-02-20 kl  21 37 36

mathaszip avatar Feb 20 '24 10:02 mathaszip