siwe
siwe copied to clipboard
spruceid
Viem support?
I created a viem version here https://github.com/feelsgoodman-web3/siwveim
Hello, we are discussing how to address this, since the library went through an audit it gets a little more complicated to replace such a vital library. Hope you understand!
So i write small lib, also welcome to testing simplified siwe with Viem 2
https://github.com/reslear/simple-siwe
Comparison
| Package | Install size | Linting | Engine | Parser |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| simple-siwe v0.1.4 | average | Viem v2 | own (beta) | |
| eip-login v0.1.0 | average | Viem v2 | - | |
| siwviem v1.3.0 | high | Viem v1 | @spruceid/siwe-parser | |
| siwe v2.3.2 | high | ethersjs | @spruceid/siwe-parser | |
| siwe-viem v0.1.0 | high | Viem v2 | @spruceid/siwe-parser |
We are not planning to add support for viem but would welcome a contribution. As this library already supports both ethers.js v5 and v6 I believe the "crypto backend" is abstracted enough to make such addition relatively easily, unless I'm missing something.
We are not planning to add support for viem but would welcome a contribution. As this library already supports both ethers.js v5 and v6 I believe the "crypto backend" is abstracted enough to make such addition relatively easily, unless I'm missing something.
I'd say that you are missing what we believe is very important. Quite a lot of websites use Viem/Wagmi. And quite a lot, like us, the only usage of ethers is from this package, leading to an unnecesary increase of package downloading from the users which leads to a worse user experience, specially on smartphones / contries with slow Internet connections.
@nfts2me Yes and no, there's also a deps problem (like parsers based on apg-js), See my Comparison above packages on viem ~2mb.
however siwe 2.8mb + parser 2.66 + ethers 18.8MB = ~23mb
hence the motivation to make https://github.com/reslear/simple-siwe a scaled-down copy without dependencies