Session + redis -> Lost data when run many requests

[schotten]

After migration to spring parent 2.5.0 from 3.4.0, the spring data redis lost data the intermittently. I isolated one specific scenario that reproduce in my machine.

Enviroment:

1. I use the default Spring integration

2. I save the object complex in spring session through below code:

3. I use the last version of redis (7.4.1)

Scenario

My aplication execute the endpoint /front/adapters/grouper/23866860 After the response of backend, the front call the requests in parallel

• /front/constraints/list/disabled
• /front/user-requirements/user/forced/dto
• /front/tree
• /front/user-requirements/recommendation/disabled
• /front/tree/nodes/filter/autocomplete

In my secondary user interactive, i call the endpoint /front/drawings-urs[]

My problem: When, i started the application in every firsty execution, the system lost data session in the parallel requests. I created one LoggableDispatcherServlet to log session informations, please follow the file: LoggableDispatcherServlet.txt

In log from LoggableDispatcherServlet, please, check the order of request/response. I converted from table the better visualization

event	type	-	endpoint
1	IN	-	/front/adapters/grouper/23866860-urs[]
2	OUT	-	/front/adapters/grouper/23866860-urs[{"id"100,"keyUr":"Project.motor.hasBrake"}]
3	IN	-	/front/constraints/list/disabled-urs[]
4	IN	-	/front/user-requirements/user/forced/dto-urs[]
5	IN	-	/front/tree-urs[]
6	IN	-	/front/user-requirements/recommendation/disabled-urs[]
7	IN	-	/front/tree/nodes/filter/autocomplete-urs[]
8	OUT	-	/front/constraints/list/disabled-urs[]
9	OUT	-	/front/user-requirements/user/forced/dto-urs[]
10	OUT	-	/front/user-requirements/recommendation/disabled-urs[]
11	OUT	-	/front/tree-urs[]
12	IN	-	/front/projects/status/allStatus-urs[{"id"100,"keyUr":"Project.motor.hasBrake"}]
13	OUT	-	/front/projects/status/allStatus-urs[{"id"100,"keyUr":"Project.motor.hasBrake"}]
14	OUT	-	/front/tree/nodes/filter/autocomplete-urs[]
15	IN	-	/front/drawings-urs[]

Check:

• In the line 1, the user call the execution endpoint /front/adapters/grouper/23866860 and not have data in session.
• in the line 2, the system filled data in session ({"id"100,"keyUr":"Project.motor.hasBrake"})
• Lines 3,4,5,6,7 automatic called data from backand, after the response of line 2 and not have the session data in the start.
• Line 12 and 13 have session spring data
• line 15, the next interaction to user, the data was lost.

Please, verify and fix this problem, please. If need more information, please tell me in the response this question.

[ArjanSchouten]

I have a similar problem with @EnableRedisWebSession in the reactive implementation. The first request has data but after multiple concurrent calls, the logging is:

2024-12-04T10:30:12.620+01:00 DEBUG 7771 --- [a-gateway] [ctor-http-nio-7] o.s.s.w.s.u.m.OrServerWebExchangeMatcher : matched
2024-12-04T10:30:12.620+01:00 DEBUG 7771 --- [a-gateway] [ctor-http-nio-7] a.DelegatingReactiveAuthorizationManager : Checking authorization on '/api/my-path' using org.springframework.security.authorization.AuthenticatedReactiveAuthorizationManager@7ce32811
2024-12-04T10:30:12.620+01:00 DEBUG 7771 --- [a-gateway] [     parallel-8] ebSessionServerSecurityContextRepository : No SecurityContext found in WebSession: 'org.springframework.session.web.server.session.SpringSessionWebSessionStore$SpringSessionWebSession@59238507'
2024-12-04T10:30:12.621+01:00 DEBUG 7771 --- [a-gateway] [     parallel-1] ebSessionServerSecurityContextRepository : No SecurityContext found in WebSession: 'org.springframework.session.web.server.session.SpringSessionWebSessionStore$SpringSessionWebSession@3bc005b0'
2024-12-04T10:30:12.621+01:00 DEBUG 7771 --- [a-gateway] [     parallel-1] o.s.s.w.s.a.AuthorizationWebFilter       : Authorization failed: Access Denied
2024-12-04T10:30:12.621+01:00 DEBUG 7771 --- [a-gateway] [     parallel-8] o.s.s.w.s.a.AuthorizationWebFilter       : Authorization failed: Access Denied
2024-12-04T10:30:12.624+01:00 DEBUG 7771 --- [a-gateway] [     parallel-1] ebSessionServerSecurityContextRepository : No SecurityContext found in WebSession: 'org.springframework.session.web.server.session.SpringSessionWebSessionStore$SpringSessionWebSession@3bc005b0'
2024-12-04T10:30:12.624+01:00 DEBUG 7771 --- [a-gateway] [     parallel-8] ebSessionServerSecurityContextRepository : No SecurityContext found in WebSession: 'org.springframework.session.web.server.session.SpringSessionWebSessionStore$SpringSessionWebSession@59238507'

I compared it with Spring boot 3.3.5 and what seems to be different is the thread:

2024-12-04T10:34:21.692+01:00 DEBUG 8084 --- [a-gateway] [ioEventLoop-5-1] ebSessionServerSecurityContextRepository : Found SecurityContext 'SecurityContextImpl [Authentication=OAuth2AuthenticationToken [...]]' in WebSession: 'org.springframework.session.web.server.session.SpringSessionWebSessionStore$SpringSessionWebSession@257c99b3'

Maybe a concurrency issue?