spacebarchat icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
spacebarchat copied to clipboard

ActivityPub support?

Open slrgt opened this issue 1 year ago • 6 comments

Are there plans for adding activitypub support?

slrgt avatar Mar 28 '25 00:03 slrgt

I'm not a maintainer, but I doubt federation will properly happen under spacebar, and if it did, it'd likely use polyproto, due to it being made for discord like stuff, though no guarantees on anything,

MathMan05 avatar Mar 28 '25 00:03 MathMan05

Why polyproto? Activitypub has millions of users and would make spacebar a better hub of information since people would be able to make their server indexed by google. This would especially be helpful for open source projects that want to have chatrooms and also for when spacebar gets discord like forum channels

slrgt avatar Mar 28 '25 00:03 slrgt

Maddy was looking to implement it but not much came from it, there's a branch for it though iirc. Imo it's also not entirely in the scope of the project.

Puyodead1 avatar Mar 28 '25 00:03 Puyodead1

Why polyproto? Activitypub has millions of users and would make spacebar a better hub of information since people would be able to make their server indexed by google. This would especially be helpful for open source projects that want to have chatrooms and also for when spacebar gets discord like forum channels

The goal of the project has always been about creating a re-implementation of discord also, activitypub is outside that scope.

Puyodead1 avatar Mar 28 '25 00:03 Puyodead1

Why polyproto? Activitypub has millions of users and would make spacebar a better hub of information since people would be able to make their server indexed by google. This would especially be helpful for open source projects that want to have chatrooms and also for when spacebar gets discord like forum channels

Activitypub just isn't meant for discord like apps, and the project that'll likely superseded spacebar is using it. It'd be neat if Activitypub was somehow made into the federation protical, I just don't find it to be very likely, anyhow spacebar isn't a very active project anymore, there's a few people who sometimes make commits, but that's really it. If you'd like to get spacebar working better, you may do so, and I'm sure everyone would really like that, but federation is complicated and whatnot

MathMan05 avatar Mar 28 '25 00:03 MathMan05

Which project superseding spacebar is using activitypub?

On Thu, Mar 27, 2025 at 8:47 PM, MathMan05 @.***(mailto:On Thu, Mar 27, 2025 at 8:47 PM, MathMan05 < wrote:

Why polyproto? Activitypub has millions of users and would make spacebar a better hub of information since people would be able to make their server indexed by google. This would especially be helpful for open source projects that want to have chatrooms and also for when spacebar gets discord like forum channels

Activitypub just isn't meant for discord like apps, and the project that'll likely superseded spacebar is using it. It'd be neat if Activitypub was somehow made into the federation protical, I just don't find it to be very likely, anyhow spacebar isn't a very active project anymore, there's a few people who sometimes make commits, but that's really it. If you'd like to get spacebar working better, you may do so, and I'm sure everyone would really like that, but federation is complicated and whatnot

— Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub, or unsubscribe. You are receiving this because you authored the thread.Message ID: @.***>

[MathMan05] MathMan05 left a comment (spacebarchat/spacebarchat#225)

Why polyproto? Activitypub has millions of users and would make spacebar a better hub of information since people would be able to make their server indexed by google. This would especially be helpful for open source projects that want to have chatrooms and also for when spacebar gets discord like forum channels

Activitypub just isn't meant for discord like apps, and the project that'll likely superseded spacebar is using it. It'd be neat if Activitypub was somehow made into the federation protical, I just don't find it to be very likely, anyhow spacebar isn't a very active project anymore, there's a few people who sometimes make commits, but that's really it. If you'd like to get spacebar working better, you may do so, and I'm sure everyone would really like that, but federation is complicated and whatnot

— Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub, or unsubscribe. You are receiving this because you authored the thread.Message ID: @.***>

slrgt avatar Mar 28 '25 16:03 slrgt