os-installer icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
os-installer copied to clipboard

Suggest A Username based on Real Name

Open snwh opened this issue 9 years ago • 9 comments

Most people probably don't have a specific username in mind when they're setting up a user account, and I'd wager the majority of people use a username based on their real name anyway, so suggesting a username would save a few seconds of their install time.

For example, "John Doe" would suggest jdoe or "Jane" would suggest jane

And this suggestion mechanism wouldn't inconvenience users who have a specific username in mind (e.g. soluslover22) since they'd still have to type it in anyway.

--- Want to back this issue? **[Post a bounty on it!](https://www.bountysource.com/issues/35866577-suggest-a-username-based-on-real-name?utm_campaign=plugin&utm_content=tracker%2F2994527&utm_medium=issues&utm_source=github)** We accept bounties via [Bountysource](https://www.bountysource.com/?utm_campaign=plugin&utm_content=tracker%2F2994527&utm_medium=issues&utm_source=github).

snwh avatar Jul 08 '16 17:07 snwh

It would be ideal to put the user account name above the username field in the installer to make this processes easier.

philipzae avatar Jul 25 '16 20:07 philipzae

Yeah that too, I forgot to mention that in the original report.

snwh avatar Jul 27 '16 02:07 snwh

Possibly the code can be pulled from System > Users > Add User

philipzae avatar Jul 28 '16 07:07 philipzae

This isn't an issue with code, this is an issue with inventing problems that don't exist. We do not support a spam-click-thru model

ikeydoherty avatar Jul 28 '16 10:07 ikeydoherty

So we can only report issues with code?

snwh avatar Jul 28 '16 15:07 snwh

What? I didn't say that. The answer was in response to code that I could use, and I pointed out this isn't a code issue. I don't really see how this functionality helps. If you can link to something suggesting that this behaviour isn't intrusive and annoying, then yeah I'll consider it

ikeydoherty avatar Jul 28 '16 17:07 ikeydoherty

The point of the functionality is to reduce the amount of typing a user does and it be intuitive in doing so.

philipzae avatar Jul 28 '16 19:07 philipzae

@ikeydoherty okay, but it read like that to me. 😉

I don't see how this is intrusive and annoying, it is simply a suggestion which I'd argue is helpful. It doesn't even add a step, it removes one for a lot of people and it would only impact those who find the suggested username unsatisfactory and would have to backspace it, which is a very minor trade off (in a text box you already have to interact with).

Most graphical installers I've used have this behaviour: Fedora's, Ubiquity. Even the Mac OS X first-run setup is based on real name (but in this case you have no option to set a username).

snwh avatar Jul 28 '16 19:07 snwh

I'm not sure what your argument against this is aside from "it promotes click-through" which it does not do, it's a simple time saver.

snwh avatar Jul 28 '16 19:07 snwh