filmic-blender icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
filmic-blender copied to clipboard

Adobe RGB

Open bjorn3 opened this issue 8 years ago • 17 comments

Please support conversion to Adobe RGB.

bjorn3 avatar Feb 21 '17 19:02 bjorn3

It is on the TODO. Sadly they are display referred, but I will support the transform.

sobotka avatar Feb 21 '17 20:02 sobotka

Any news on this?

Eneen avatar Jul 13 '18 12:07 Eneen

It will likely be added in the next wider gamut iteration, but not into this repository. The stanzas shouldn't be too difficult to design for those keen.

sobotka avatar Jul 13 '18 16:07 sobotka

Just a reminder, when to expect this?

Eneen avatar Nov 01 '20 11:11 Eneen

For input or display?

sobotka avatar Nov 15 '20 17:11 sobotka

I think both.

Eneen avatar Nov 15 '20 18:11 Eneen

You “think”? What is your context? Are you loading AdobeRGB imagery or do you have an AdobeRGB display?

sobotka avatar Nov 15 '20 18:11 sobotka

I'm using adobergb display (dell u2713h) and have some textures in adobergb, own made backplates mainly. They are currently converted into srgb ofc.

Eneen avatar Nov 15 '20 20:11 Eneen

OCIO v1 doesn’t provide a clean mechanism to clip out of gamut values, so you’ll need to take that into account in your own pipeline. Give me a few...

sobotka avatar Nov 15 '20 20:11 sobotka

Do you also plan to add Rec.2020 and DCI-P3? I don't use them but looks like they will be needed at some point.

Eneen avatar Nov 15 '20 20:11 Eneen

I'm not too concerned with things that people don't have or aren't using exclusively yet. It requires actual people with actual needs and hardware to test.

Please test https://github.com/sobotka/filmic-blender/tree/with-AdobeRGB

sobotka avatar Nov 15 '20 22:11 sobotka

Pure AdobeRGB works, but Filmic Log View Transform doesn't, on both sRGB and Adobe. I've checked master branch and it works ok there, for sRGB ofc. On a daily basis I use config distributed with blender and I see that input color space naming has changed:

  • Non-Color is now Non-Color Data
  • sRGB is now sRGB OETF This way all maps are now switched into sRGB OETF. This is quite a problem with non-color maps like normals and roughness as it requires manual adjustment of all non-color maps in all current projects. Is it possible to keep previous names, just "sRGB" and "Non-Color"?

Eneen avatar Nov 16 '20 17:11 Eneen

Aliases are a part of OCIO v2. I’m not mangling up this config to appease Blender poor design choices. Other folks using other software use it too.

There are specific roles that are set and Blender should honour, but that’s on Blender.

https://github.com/sobotka/filmic-blender/blob/master/config.ocio#L22

What is wrong with the AdobeRGB Filmic Log specifically?

sobotka avatar Nov 16 '20 17:11 sobotka

For both sRGB and AdobeRGB Filmic log doesn't work, nothing happens when I switch into. Even greyscale doesn't work.

Eneen avatar Nov 16 '20 18:11 Eneen

Odd. It worked when I tested it. Will check when I have a moment later.

sobotka avatar Nov 16 '20 19:11 sobotka

Ah, my bad, looks like it works fine. Take a look @ line 52, shouldn't be AdobeRGB there? And line 199 in description, same thing.

Eneen avatar Dec 04 '20 11:12 Eneen

Good spot. The AdobeRGB wasn’t working obviously, due to being Apple’s Display P3. Give it a test. This is untested as I committed the fixes via the browser.

sobotka avatar Dec 04 '20 12:12 sobotka