slsa icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
slsa copied to clipboard

feedback: version SLSA 1.0 dropping / reducing scope from 0.1 is weird

Open msmeissn opened this issue 1 year ago • 3 comments

Sorry for not keeping up with the SLSA 1.0 development.

It looks weird to me that you would declare it SLSA 1.0.

  • it has less requirements and reduced scope compared to 0.1
  • quite some work (and big open gaps) is only planned to be filled again for the future past 1.0
  • it severely devalues adoption work done by early adopters of SLSA 0.1 (like my employer SUSE)

So I would suggest not calling it SLSA 1.0.

  • 1.0 would suggest completeness which is not the case. Perhaps 0.2 might fit better.
  • if you want to stick with the 1.0, you could call it differently to match content, e.g. "SLSA Build 1.0"

msmeissn avatar Apr 06 '23 12:04 msmeissn