linkding icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
linkding copied to clipboard

Leaving description field empty when creating a bookmark

Open ajeetdsouza opened this issue 4 years ago • 5 comments

How does one leave the description field empty when creating a new bookmark? Currently, leaving it empty just fills it up using the website's content.

ajeetdsouza avatar Apr 09 '20 10:04 ajeetdsouza

Hmm, that's not really a use case I considered. I thought that having more data is always useful, for example for searching where it also looks at the description. The input was only for cases where where there is no default content or you want to override it.

I tried with space, but that is ignored. The only thing you can do right now is to enter a single non-space character into the field like -. Could you elaborate on your use-case?

sissbruecker avatar Apr 09 '20 13:04 sissbruecker

The auto-retrieved description is not always a good one, and I do keep my titles descriptive enough, so I don't really need the description field except in very specific scenarios.

While I am currently using a - in place of the description, this does feel like a less-than-ideal solution. It would be great if you could handle the - case separately to blank out the field!

ajeetdsouza avatar Apr 09 '20 13:04 ajeetdsouza

I prefer short titles and succinct descriptions. To achieve this I often end up editing both fields.

On Pinboard.in I sometimes leave description empty, but only when I check off "read later" (a collection I keep short, and update often).

Here I would replace the checkbox with a #readlater tag.

If the description is always auto-populated, never left empty by default, then I'm fine with it being required.

But if I have to spend time to fill in something helpful and succinct, then I would prefer the description field to be optional (left blank).

Gatada avatar Mar 16 '21 07:03 Gatada

When saving a Linkding bookmark, if we don't enter a description the description is automatically populated in the bookmark. Please create a checkbox to disable the description from being auto populated. linkding02

joel72265 avatar Apr 27 '23 11:04 joel72265

description retrieved from websites may be promotive and bloated (for SEO purpose?), though inserting a non-blank character is a workaround.

Kosette avatar May 08 '24 12:05 Kosette