sentora-core icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
sentora-core copied to clipboard

FTP Suspend Bug?

Open Dexxa1024 opened this issue 10 years ago • 9 comments

When you suspend an account, the web page and client panel suspends, But still allows you access to the ftp using the normal client accounts details,

so customers still have access to their ftp account even when the service is suspended

Dexxa1024 avatar Feb 25 '15 16:02 Dexxa1024

Ok we will check that.

MBlagui avatar Feb 25 '15 18:02 MBlagui

Is't it correct ? It enables a user to backup his account content when it got suspended, ie before a complete removal of his account. I have the feeling that also disabling the ftp may be an option but must not be automatic.

5050 avatar Feb 26 '15 09:02 5050

Yeah i agree! - if you want to stop your users access altogether they should 'delete' instead of 'suspend'

Sent from my iPhone

On 26 Feb 2015, at 09:04, Pascal Peyremorte [email protected] wrote:

Is't it correct ? It enables a user to backup his account content when it is suspended, ie before a complete removal of his account. I have the feeling that also disabling the ftp may be an option but must not be automatic.

— Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub.

allebb avatar Feb 26 '15 09:02 allebb

I don't agree, when an admin suspend user account, it means we ban him access FTP/EMAIL/WEB.

In hosting this is not over being good and offering a way to backup. If the admin would allow that he would enable back the account and delete the websites or suspend them ( using vhost settings).

Some time we suspend an account to force a customer to pay his bills and if he is able to access his data some will grab them and flee away.

So means that apply too to emails?

MBlagui avatar Feb 26 '15 09:02 MBlagui

So just to confirm then, you're not talking about when the account is suspended for bandwidth over usage? - Which is what I thought you meant?

On 26 February 2015 at 09:41, MBlagui [email protected] wrote:

I don't agree, when an admin suspend user account, it means we ban him access FTP/EMAIL/WEB.

In hosting this is not over being good and offering a way to backup. If the admin would allow that he would enable back the account and delete the websites or suspend them ( using vhost settings).

Some time we suspend an account to force a customer to pay his bills and if he is able to access his data some will grab them and flee away.

— Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub https://github.com/sentora/sentora-core/issues/131#issuecomment-76148628 .

allebb avatar Feb 26 '15 09:02 allebb

I agree that suspend should suspend all services.

If a user wants a backup. They can request a zip file from the admin.

FTP doesn't give access to emails or other non web root assets.

Philip McGaw www.philipmcgaw.com 07969502077

@Philip_McGaw

On 26 Feb 2015, at 09:41, MBlagui [email protected] wrote:

I don't agree, when an admin suspend user account, it means we ban him access FTP/EMAIL/WEB.

In hosting this is not over being good and offering a way to backup. If the admin would allow that he would enable back the account and delete the websites or suspend them ( using vhost settings).

Some time we suspend an account to force a customer to pay his bills and if he is able to access his data some will grab them and flee away.

— Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub.

PhilipMcGaw avatar Feb 26 '15 10:02 PhilipMcGaw

Some customers and use hosting services to host XMBC media content for their media centres and can ftp stream them, if the ftp still works after suspend then they still get a service when they are suspended. or if a user uploads a script that's not legal and you need proof that they have used the account for illegal activities and you suspend them, They can still delete the files and then if you report it and they've deleted it. Mostly every panel suspends every service when an accounts been suspended, it would be great if this panel can do the same.

Dexxa1024 avatar Feb 26 '15 14:02 Dexxa1024

@bobsta63 It maybe a good idea, lets say if the user doesnt pay on time, you delete the account and then he pays, Then you'd have to go through the hassle of resetting up his/hers account and everything working again, but then theres the other way where you just suspend and then unsuspend and the accounts back online in full contact.

I suspend clients and then when they dont pay within a vaild time frame then it gets deleted, if we just delete the account instead of suspending then that makes the host look bad, we just know people will be going on forums and complaining "this host didnt suspend my account but deleted it" lines :)

I ment for when you suspend for abuse, non payment etc :)

Dexxa1024 avatar Feb 26 '15 15:02 Dexxa1024

I see your point(s) - we'll work to implement in the next release!

Sent from my iPhone

On 26 Feb 2015, at 15:01, Dexxa1024 [email protected] wrote:

@bobsta63 It maybe a good idea, lets say if the user doesnt pay on time, you delete the account and then he pays, Then you'd have to go through the hassle of resetting up his/hers account and everything working again, but then theres the other way where you just suspend and then unsuspend and the accounts back online in full contact.

I suspend clients and then when they dont pay within a vaild time frame then it gets deleted, if we just delete the account instead of suspending then that makes the host look bad, we just know people will be going on forums and complaining "this host didnt suspend my account but deleted it" lines :)

— Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub.

allebb avatar Feb 26 '15 15:02 allebb