semgrep-rules icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
semgrep-rules copied to clipboard

removing rule that detects just parameter names

Open 6f6d6172 opened this issue 3 months ago • 1 comments

Hi folks,

It's me deleting another rule. This time it's a rule that basically flags specific parameter names as a high severity finding. I get what it's going for but this rule isn't really useful, especially when the guidance is "don't use those parameters". This rule can't tell if you're using the parameters safely or not, and the guidance might cause someone who was doing something safely to do something more dangerous (e.g. using params[:account_id] instead of params.permit(...) and assigning it manually to a model).

Regarding the "spirit" of what this rule is trying to detect, I don't think it's possible without doing some sort of control flow analysis. While it's a different tool entirely, I've had success using this Rubocop rule I wrote a couple years ago.

6f6d6172 avatar Mar 26 '24 22:03 6f6d6172