arduino-BLEPeripheral icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
arduino-BLEPeripheral copied to clipboard

Published 20 hours ago • verified publisher icon sandeepmistry

nRF8001: Dynamic data not saved unless disconnected from central

Open prossel opened this issue 7 years ago • 5 comments

Symptoms

Using with RedBearLab BLE Shield v 2.1 on Arduino Uno, the peripheral cannot reconnect after first successful connection. Unless is it disconnected first from central without being powered down. That is the only way I have found to trigger the save of dynamic data in EEPROM.

To reproduce

  • Open HIDKeyboard example
  • Adjust BLE_REQ and BLE_RDY pins to specific board configuration
  • Upload to Arduino
  • Connect to central (tested with MacBook, OS X 10.11.6)
  • Test from Serial Monitor by sending a few keys, they come back through the HID. (To break the loop, click somewhere where a few keystrokes are not harmful)
  • Disconnect the Arduino (power down)
  • Reconnect Arduino
  • See that it does not reconnect

More information

To make it work, after connecting to the central, use the Bluetooth menu to disconnect the HIDKeyboard or turn off Bluetooth. Do not power off the Arduino. When the connection is lost on Arduino, we can see in the serial monitor that the dynamic data is read (from the shield) and stored to EEPROM (to see these messages, on has to activate debug traces in nRF8001.cpp, search for #define NRF_8001_DEBUG).

I wonder why theses dynamic data is only saved when the peripheral is disconnected from host and not when the bond is successfully established. Also I don't see the ACI_EVT_BOND_STATUS message come when the peripheral is connected (and bond) for the first time.

prossel avatar Mar 21 '17 17:03 prossel

@prossel this is a limitation of the nRF8001 as far as I understand.

Let me know if you have any ideas on how we can avoid this.

sandeepmistry avatar Mar 27 '17 01:03 sandeepmistry

I would suggest to try requesting the dynamic data after the connection has been successfully established, without waiting for the central to disconnect. Maybe nRF8001 support could help find a way.

prossel avatar Mar 28 '17 18:03 prossel

I would suggest to try requesting the dynamic data after the connection has been successfully established, without waiting for the central to disconnect.

@prossel I don't think this is possible, have you tried it out yourself. If so, please submit a PR.

sandeepmistry avatar Apr 10 '17 00:04 sandeepmistry

@sandeepmistry I tried but with no success.

prossel avatar Apr 10 '17 15:04 prossel

Ok, we'll just leave this issue open to track it as a known limitation.

sandeepmistry avatar Apr 16 '17 23:04 sandeepmistry