speakerinnen_liste icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
speakerinnen_liste copied to clipboard

check if certain sites can be scraped again by google

Open zaziemo opened this issue 6 years ago • 3 comments

context: if people change their name, the slug /firstname-name changes as well.

The link with the previous name does not work anymore and the user gets an error page. Please check: Is it possible to tell google to crawl a certain site again (eg. if name changes)?

zaziemo avatar Feb 13 '19 16:02 zaziemo

Idea: Women can enter a name for the url themselves. If the name changes (for example, on marriage), they can change the field themselves, or we suggest that two urls refer to the same profile.

sabrina-ulbrich avatar Apr 04 '19 18:04 sabrina-ulbrich

Are users aware of this problem? Can we warn them not to change their names? OR Is it a feature that is not yet implemented? How would we want to implement it? Would it be a mandatory field? What happens with all the users who changed their names so far?

netagonen avatar Apr 06 '20 18:04 netagonen

@netagonen this is something that is already implemented. We use the gem friendly-id to make routing by name instead of id possible (default Rails Route .../profiles/1 vs. .../profiles/maren-heltsche`). This comes with the downside that if the name changes the slug (last part of the route) also changes.

I think we shouldn't prevent our users to change their names. Nobody would do that unless it is really necessary. I also would prefer not to let people themselves decide how their slug might be named as @sabrina-ulbrich suggested.

As I described above it would be great if we could "tell" google somehow to crawl the site again (because to my knowledge this is the only context the problem really is a problem) or alternatively we could see if we have a redirection from the old URL to the new one as @sabrina-ulbrich also suggested.

zaziemo avatar Apr 11 '20 10:04 zaziemo