Installing gems from gists is underdocumented.

[x-yuri]

https://github.com/rubygems/bundler-site/blob/b86f2ccd3150009bd9bb25d961a462a880631116/source/v2.0/guides/git.html.haml#L111-L121

Is this even possible, considering gists don't support directories? Was it ever?

[duckinator]

Hi! I don't know what the current plans are, but it looks like all of the default git sources (:github, :gist, and :bitbucket) were deprecated 3 years ago.

See https://github.com/rubygems/bundler/blame/d852b30b66165dbb88682f72a8929568af7e7c57/lib/bundler/dsl.rb#L288-L312 and https://github.com/rubygems/bundler/commit/598ab4bef8fefd0a11d8b4b735a6c13b2cfb2e78.

The documentation should definitely mention that they're deprecated.

---

Also, as a note: I don't think Gems technically require any subdirectories. Gemspec files set spec.require_paths = ["lib"], usually. If you replace that ["lib"] with ["."], it'll pull files from the same directory the gemspec is in.

[x-yuri]

It is indeed possible and the deprecation is canceled.

[deivid-rodriguez]

So, does this mean this can be closed, or should we still clarify this?

[olleolleolle]

I believe it means that we want the feature to be explained clearer in the Bundler site documentation.

[x-yuri]

Well, now that I've created my first gist gem :) it's all clear. Back then... I remember I was surprised that one can install gems from gists. And I was wondering how one can create one.

So, how can the docs be improved? You already have examples of installing gems from all 3 sources. And I guess they're pretty self-explanatory.

The only thing I can think of is providing an example of a gist gem. Which is more about rubygems than bundler. And if you ever created an ordinary gem, you probably have an idea how to create one in a gist.

So I leave deciding if the docs need to be improved to your discretion.

[tnir]

First of all, the canonical URL is https://bundler.io/guides/git.html, which is to be always up to date.

Per an example for gist: gem, it looks enough well-documented to me. So I would say 👍 for closing this.

[x-yuri]

Per an example for gist: gem, it looks enough well-documented to me.

You seem to be missing my point, so I'll add a comment. For a person that never created a gem, when they see the :gist source, the first question that comes to mind is, "How do I create a gem in a gist?" (At least that is likely.) And that is undocumented and not too straightforward.

But I understand that technically that is out of scope of bundler (or not exactly in the scope of). And it's not really clear how to document it. Other than by giving a simple example, and/or writing an article. In other words closing the issue also makes sense.

[deivid-rodriguez]

Actually the current gist example is actually confusing, because it reads gist: '4815162342'. And https://gist.github.com/4815162342 does not redirect to an actual gist, but to the list of gists of user named 4815162342 😆.

I guess an easy improvement is to change the reference to the sample gist @x-yuri created.