unconf17 icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
unconf17 copied to clipboard

Interviews re. how conflict is resolved in this open source community

Open earino opened this issue 7 years ago • 9 comments

I am in the final semester of a MA program in Negotiation, Conflict Resolution and Peacebuilding. I am hoping to write and publish a paper as part of my "dispute systems design" course on how open source organizations like rOpensci handle internal disagreements and disagreements with contributors. These can range from:

  • disagreements about the purpose of some code
  • the architecture of some code
  • quality of code

or deeper issues like:

  • establishing a code of conduct
  • vision for the whole organization

I would love the opportunity to talk to folks for short blocks, 5-10 minutes informally and get an understanding for how they see this sort of thing handled both inside the rOpensci community, and other tech and scientific communities they are members of.

I would share the paper and the collected data with everyone upon completion. Is this an appropriate use of time at this event?

earino avatar May 23 '17 17:05 earino

Would be super happy to chat about this, though most of my experience is related to the editorial process.

On Tue, May 23, 2017, 10:17 AM E. Ariño de la Rubia < [email protected]> wrote:

I am in the final semester of a MA program in Negotiation, Conflict Resolution and Peacebuilding. I am hoping to write and publish a paper as part of my "dispute systems design" course on how open source organizations like rOpensci handle internal disagreements and disagreements with contributors. These can range from:

  • disagreements about the purpose of some code
  • the architecture of some code
  • quality of code

or deeper issues like:

  • establishing a code of conduct
  • vision for the whole organization

I would love the opportunity to talk to folks for short blocks, 5-10 minutes informally and get an understanding for how they see this sort of thing handled both inside the rOpensci community, and other tech and scientific communities they are members of.

I would share the paper and the collected data with everyone upon completion. Is this an appropriate use of time at this event?

— You are receiving this because you are subscribed to this thread. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/ropensci/unconf17/issues/92, or mute the thread https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AAi5aBAP-dpfZMzhsAVllQyAuMpvH1jKks5r8xSlgaJpZM4NkA3j .

noamross avatar May 24 '17 23:05 noamross

happy to chat about this @earino

sckott avatar May 25 '17 00:05 sckott

Me too this is very interesting.

mdsumner avatar May 25 '17 06:05 mdsumner

I'd be happy to participate

revodavid avatar May 25 '17 14:05 revodavid

Happy to talk about this.

elinw avatar May 25 '17 14:05 elinw

wow! this is awesome :) if you have a few minutes, please ping me on slack and I will come find you. in the meantime, I built a survey, and would appreciate if you had time filling it out! thanks!

https://docs.google.com/forms/d/1u-ROBfuXRgUnxs6cNqDfWiMQUjkiDZeOkhYvuNpXBp8/viewform

earino avatar May 25 '17 22:05 earino

@earino if you send me an email about this I will fwd to a couple of people who might be interested, and will make an e-intro to you

stefaniebutland avatar May 26 '17 17:05 stefaniebutland

@stefaniebutland :-D

earino avatar May 26 '17 17:05 earino

@earino - throw back Thursdays :) Are you able to share the results of your survey? I'm looking to include a section surrounding Issue and PR conflicts/resolutions in a community I am building and found this thread in my research.

I found this to be of use as well: https://github.com/jonschlinkert/maintainers-guide-to-staying-positive

jacebryan avatar Dec 13 '18 18:12 jacebryan