lively icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
lively copied to clipboard

Taskbar theme development status

Open rocksdanister opened this issue 2 years ago • 46 comments

There are many reported bugs with taskbar theming.

Taskbar theming, similar to animated wallpaper is not officially supported by Windows and as such it is prone to breaking.

To make matters more difficult upcoming Windows update is changing the implementation.

Since it is becoming increasingly difficult to maintain this feature and its not the main focus of Lively, I am unfortunately putting taskbar theme feature development on hold for now (bugfixes and enhancements.)

As always Lively is an opensource project and development support is always more than welcome. If anyone in the community would like to take over the development and maintenance of taskbar theme feature please feel free to reach out here or through my socials.

If the feature remains in hold, it will be discontinued and I will explore other options such as to add support for third party applications like TranslucentTB maintained by my friend @sylveon.

rocksdanister avatar Feb 17 '23 04:02 rocksdanister

thank you for the information will try translucent tb

sidd1908 avatar Feb 21 '23 16:02 sidd1908

thank you. But I can't imagine Lively without taskbar theming it's amazing. but we understand you ...

thank yooooou ....

F-1y avatar Feb 22 '23 14:02 F-1y

When you open the start menu, the taskbar changes color by a second and returns it again. Also, the "smooth" mode does not look well with the standard start menu, that is, the colors are different, and do not fit. I also thank the developers for such a wonderful application and wish you the best of luck in its further development:)

LostOfSpace avatar Feb 24 '23 09:02 LostOfSpace

Thank you for this app, it is amazing. The option for visualization is it available still? I cannot seem to find it in the latest app? Link to the video showing it below. Thanks https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zU8fFkHIZXI

exodus3155 avatar Feb 26 '23 22:02 exodus3155

I just want to make it 'clear' on the desktop but 'blur' when any application is running. I used to do that with TranslucentTB when Lively taskbar settings were off. But, when I changed the wallpaper(video wallpaper) on Lively this behavior is gone! Now, I can't make that behavior again with TranslucentTB . Do I need to reboot the PC or need to do something else?

abusayed0206 avatar Mar 06 '23 12:03 abusayed0206

I don't understand why you need to disable this feature? It works great for me. All I need is to make the taskbar clear and it works great. I have windows 11 and the taskbar is too big so I use this feature to make it clear. It works great. Just becuase other features don't work doesn't mean you have to eliminate it for people like me that need it. Also is there another app out there that can make the taskbar clear? I googled it and can't find anything

TanyaTheEvil avatar Mar 16 '23 14:03 TanyaTheEvil

Just so everyone knows that TranslucentTB does not work at all. Knothing works except Lively Wallpaper. Please take the hold off of the feature that makes the taskbar clear

TanyaTheEvil avatar Mar 17 '23 14:03 TanyaTheEvil

I only used "lively" because of this feature, now I see it has been disabled and I see no reason to use it anymore. If you come back, please let me know.

gabrie1lira avatar Mar 19 '23 19:03 gabrie1lira

I don't understand why you need to disable this feature? It works great for me. All I need is to make the taskbar clear and it works great. I have windows 11 and the taskbar is too big so I use this feature to make it clear. It works great. Just becuase other features don't work doesn't mean you have to eliminate it for people like me that need it. Also is there another app out there that can make the taskbar clear? I googled it and can't find anything

I don't think he said anything about disable or eliminate the feature. Just he won't be putting his available time for this project on that feature. The feature will likely stay there, just won't receive any improvements or bugfixes in the close future.

camezcua12 avatar Mar 21 '23 13:03 camezcua12

I don't understand why you need to disable this feature? It works great for me. All I need is to make the taskbar clear and it works great. I have windows 11 and the taskbar is too big so I use this feature to make it clear. It works great. Just becuase other features don't work doesn't mean you have to eliminate it for people like me that need it. Also is there another app out there that can make the taskbar clear? I googled it and can't find anything

I don't think he said anything about disable or eliminate the feature. Just he won't be putting his available time for this project on that feature. The feature will likely stay there, just won't receive any improvements or bugfixes in the close future.

Yeah, but it on hold and to me it is one of the best features of lively wallpaper. I can't stand the large taskbar. Lively wallpaper is the only app the makes the taskbar clear. No other app or nothing will make the taskbar clear in windows 11

TanyaTheEvil avatar Mar 21 '23 16:03 TanyaTheEvil

There are many reported bugs with taskbar theming.

Taskbar theming, similar to animated wallpaper is not officially supported by Windows and as such it is prone to breaking.

To make matters more difficult upcoming Windows update is changing the implementation.

Since it is becoming increasingly difficult to maintain this feature and its not the main focus of Lively, I am unfortunately putting taskbar theme feature development on hold for now (bugfixes and enhancements.)

As always Lively is an opensource project and development support is always more than welcome. If anyone in the community would like to take over the development and maintenance of taskbar theme feature please feel free to reach out here or through my socials.

If the feature remains in hold, it will be discontinued and I will explore other options such as to add support for third party applications like TranslucentTB maintained by my friend @sylveon.

i hope you will find a solution quickly because regular task bar is so boring

s0ul-less avatar Mar 25 '23 17:03 s0ul-less

I don't understand why you need to disable this feature? It works great for me. All I need is to make the taskbar clear and it works great. I have windows 11 and the taskbar is too big so I use this feature to make it clear. It works great. Just becuase other features don't work doesn't mean you have to eliminate it for people like me that need it. Also is there another app out there that can make the taskbar clear? I googled it and can't find anything

I don't think he said anything about disable or eliminate the feature. Just he won't be putting his available time for this project on that feature. The feature will likely stay there, just won't receive any improvements or bugfixes in the close future.

Yeah, but it on hold and to me it is one of the best features of lively wallpaper. I can't stand the large taskbar. Lively wallpaper is the only app the makes the taskbar clear. No other app or nothing will make the taskbar clear in windows 11

There is a registry hack/setting to change the size of the taskbar in Windows 11. I recently did it on an install I did on a PC I built for my son. Just search the internet for change taskbar icon size.

Also, I installed Lively and the clear setting works great for me. However, I am using StartAllBack to get Windows 11 to look more like Windows 7. I even have a Quick Launch bar instead of pinned apps/icons, and made a few registry setting changes like getting back the full menu in File Explorer when you right click on a file. No more having to click more options for me.

vansmack avatar Mar 27 '23 05:03 vansmack

are we supposed to expect the feature to be back?

betroboomin avatar Mar 28 '23 20:03 betroboomin

i cant clear my taskbar. i put clear on lively wallpaper but its not working

nightmare023 avatar Apr 03 '23 10:04 nightmare023

It's quite a shame that you've felt the need to do this. I still run Windows 10 so the W11 implementation change is irrelevant to me. Like others said, TranslucentTB also doesn't work for me, but this is likely a personal issue in my case.

Luckily, I still have one faithful option to go back to: ClassicShell. Would recommend anyone still using W10 to install ClassicShell, which can make your taskbar transparent or blurred. Not sure if it works on W11, but try this open source fork if it doesn't.

GratitechHD avatar Apr 12 '23 06:04 GratitechHD

i can't clear my taskbar

LaHn89 avatar Apr 25 '23 12:04 LaHn89

Mine has been like this for the past 2 months now

Aztr1xe avatar May 02 '23 02:05 Aztr1xe

i keep trying to update lively wallpapers but it always said there was a problem. Do I need to uninstall some things or is this just a glitch? @rocksdanister

cJ-aY avatar May 05 '23 00:05 cJ-aY

I never had any problems with it?? The only thing is when my display changes such as when I would switch from my xbox to pc or whenever I turned my monitor on it would turn purple but a simple fix is just press windows key twice

LucidActives avatar Jun 23 '23 07:06 LucidActives

I never had any problems with it?? The only thing is when my display changes such as when I would switch from my xbox to pc or whenever I turned my monitor on it would turn purple but a simple fix is just press windows key twice

My PC doesn't let me do anything to the taskbar, no matter what. I've tried factory resetting it and using TB. I'm just starting to think that there is something wrong in general

Aztr1xe avatar Jun 23 '23 07:06 Aztr1xe

TranslucentTB now supports the new taskbar - you can combine it with Lively to achieve the same effect now. Both programs shouldn't be causing any issues to each other, though you would need to disable the transparency effect in Lively prior.

sylveon avatar Jul 11 '23 07:07 sylveon

thx for the info it was really helpful

headphones6 avatar Jul 12 '23 01:07 headphones6

[like] Cjay PERKINS reacted to your message:


From: headphones6 @.> Sent: Wednesday, July 12, 2023 1:37:13 AM To: rocksdanister/lively @.> Cc: Cjay PERKINS @.>; Comment @.> Subject: Re: [rocksdanister/lively] Taskbar theme development status (Issue #1569)

thx for the info

— Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHubhttps://github.com/rocksdanister/lively/issues/1569#issuecomment-1631721993, or unsubscribehttps://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/A7T3VY5PSR7U47OFV6767NLXPX5UTANCNFSM6AAAAAAU67U75I. You are receiving this because you commented.Message ID: @.***>

cJ-aY avatar Jul 12 '23 01:07 cJ-aY

[like] Cjay PERKINS reacted to your message:

Nikitapro0017 avatar Jul 12 '23 18:07 Nikitapro0017

There are many reported bugs with taskbar theming.

Taskbar theming, similar to animated wallpaper is not officially supported by Windows and as such it is prone to breaking.

To make matters more difficult upcoming Windows update is changing the implementation.

Since it is becoming increasingly difficult to maintain this feature and its not the main focus of Lively, I am unfortunately putting taskbar theme feature development on hold for now (bugfixes and enhancements.)

As always Lively is an opensource project and development support is always more than welcome. If anyone in the community would like to take over the development and maintenance of taskbar theme feature please feel free to reach out here or through my socials.

If the feature remains in hold, it will be discontinued and I will explore other options such as to add support for third party applications like TranslucentTB maintained by my friend @sylveon.

There are many reported bugs with taskbar theming.

Taskbar theming, similar to animated wallpaper is not officially supported by Windows and as such it is prone to breaking.

To make matters more difficult upcoming Windows update is changing the implementation.

Since it is becoming increasingly difficult to maintain this feature and its not the main focus of Lively, I am unfortunately putting taskbar theme feature development on hold for now (bugfixes and enhancements.)

As always Lively is an opensource project and development support is always more than welcome. If anyone in the community would like to take over the development and maintenance of taskbar theme feature please feel free to reach out here or through my socials.

If the feature remains in hold, it will be discontinued and I will explore other options such as to add support for third party applications like TranslucentTB maintained by my friend @sylveon.

i just love it those animated wallpaper. nice and simple. #open source software.

SURESH750-DEBUG avatar Jul 16 '23 18:07 SURESH750-DEBUG

TranslucentTB esta funcionando junto com o Lively na data de hoje, uso Windows 11.

JorgelucasBr avatar Jul 24 '23 18:07 JorgelucasBr

You would think windows would get a hint. and give us transparency and live wallpapers As part of the windows experience. I think they're mostly focused on AI. I'm tired of using third party apps. Even though lively wallpapers. is one of the best apps I've seen. and I hope this developer keeps challenging himself. Do me a favor, bro, don't quit. The taskbar in the themes and everything. Keep trying.

zain1806481 avatar Jul 25 '23 20:07 zain1806481

But bro we have to use taskbar theme. How can we use? Pls bro.

Professor1618 avatar Jul 30 '23 14:07 Professor1618

You would think windows would get a hint. and give us transparency and live wallpapers As part of the windows experience. I think they're mostly focused on AI. I'm tired of using third party apps. Even though lively wallpapers. is one of the best apps I've seen. and I hope this developer keeps challenging himself. Do me a favor, bro, don't quit. The taskbar in the themes and everything. Keep trying.

You're right, but it's also very empty. Please give the author some help, such as money

Deng-Xian-Sheng avatar Sep 09 '23 13:09 Deng-Xian-Sheng

The Task bar thing is really cool

mosesarulvin avatar Sep 29 '23 17:09 mosesarulvin