add an option to block a module

[vchepkov]

trafficstars

It would be convenient if there was some option to blacklist a module or freeze module to a certain version.

For instance, if you have only Redhat based servers, there is no reason to install puppetlabs/apt or gentoo/portage. 'freeze' a version also can be handy, for example, keep puppetlabs/firewall at version 1.8.1, since 1.8.2 doesn't properly handle IPv6.

[rnelson0]

Can you describe how you would imagine implementing such configuration options? What you'd expect a config file might look like, for instance.

[vchepkov]

What if there was a configuration file Puppetfile.gen, for example:

mod 'puppetlabs/firewall', '1.8.1'
mod 'puppetlabs/apt', '0'
mod 'gentoo/portage', '0'

[rnelson0]

What about a YAML config? (parsing freeform text just seems fragile)

---
freeze:
  puppetlabs/firewall: '1.8.1'
ignore:
- puppetlabs/apt

[vchepkov]

Even better

[earsdown]

How about command line options? For example:

-r/--raw firewall -x/--exclude apt

Where raw modules are left as-is (e.g. as per input Puppetfile) and excluded modules are never included in the output Puppetfile. Specify option multiple times for multiple modules.

This approach would mean we won't need to invent and deal with another file format.

[vchepkov]

I suppose a script with very long command line can be used instead of config file, but it's less convenient and you are subject of ARG_MAX limitations, albeit lengthy

[rnelson0]

Changed the title to use better terminology.