multi-vector-simulator icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
multi-vector-simulator copied to clipboard

Negative value of degree of autonomy

Open paragpatil39 opened this issue 4 years ago • 4 comments

The value of degree of autonomy (DOA) comes out negative when there is only DSO source of electricity. Theoretically, according to the following definition of DOA, when my consumption is completely satisfied with the DSO electricity, the DOA should be 0. However, because of the efficiency of the transformers, there is more consumption from DSO than the electricity need. This is a reason the DOA is coming out to be negative.

image

Checklist to make sure that the bug report is complete:

  • [x] OS: Winows, 10
  • [x] Branch: dev, updated on 22-02-2021
  • [ ] If applicable: Attach full error message
  • [x] If applicable: Share screenshots/images of your problem issue ss
  • [ ] If applicable: Share used input data

paragpatil39 avatar Feb 22 '21 18:02 paragpatil39

@TheOneAndra @Bachibouzouk I would like to address this issue of negative value of degree of autonomy.

paragpatil39 avatar Feb 22 '21 18:02 paragpatil39

Thanks @paragpatil39! I personally would say that we can leave this as is, but add a note in the DOA definition.

The simple solution to avoid negative DOA would be to not have conversion assets with efficiencies between the energy provider sources and the demands. Of course, when the system grows more complex, this can not be solved easily anymore.

smartie2076 avatar Feb 23 '21 10:02 smartie2076

The value of degree of autonomy (DOA) comes out negative when there is only DSO source of electricity.

The negative DOA can also occur when the DSO is the main source of electricity but still not the only one: This system resulted in a DOA = -0.066 .(Last column is the aggregated flow). grafik

TheOneAndra avatar Feb 23 '21 10:02 TheOneAndra

We can close this with a validity check in E.

smartie2076 avatar Apr 06 '21 10:04 smartie2076