Delta icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
Delta copied to clipboard

Dropbox Access for App Only?

Open stanton119 opened this issue 6 years ago • 5 comments

Thanks for a great app! When syncing with Dropbox it lists Delta as requiring full dropbox access. GBA4iOS required the app folder only. Is there any reason why Delta requires full read/write access to dropbox outside of its own app folder?

stanton119 avatar Jan 16 '20 12:01 stanton119

Came here searching for this exact request. Right now the app requires us to grant full access to everything in Dropbox, but Dropbox supports app folders, where the app has full access only to a special app folder. I can’t justify granting full/full Dropbox access from a privacy and security perspective, but an app folder solves that whole issue. Thank you!!

cameronetchart avatar May 21 '20 21:05 cameronetchart

Came here searching for this exact request. Right now the app requires us to grant full access to everything in Dropbox, but Dropbox supports app folders, where the app has full access only to a special app folder. I can’t justify granting full/full Dropbox access from a privacy and security perspective, but an app folder solves that whole issue. Thank you!!

It only gives access to a shared folder named “delta emulator”, not your entire account.

dlevi309 avatar May 22 '20 05:05 dlevi309

Came here searching for this exact request. Right now the app requires us to grant full access to everything in Dropbox, but Dropbox supports app folders, where the app has full access only to a special app folder. I can’t justify granting full/full Dropbox access from a privacy and security perspective, but an app folder solves that whole issue. Thank you!!

It only gives access to a shared folder named “delta emulator”, not your entire account.

That doesn’t appear to be true according to the screen my Dropbox app gives me when I try to link. When apps use the Dropbox “app folder” feature I recall seeing a different message. The “files and folders” message should mean full Dropbox, unless I’m misreading this (and I haven’t hit allow to find out more).

https://help.dropbox.com/installs-integrations/third-party/third-party-apps

image

cameronetchart avatar May 22 '20 05:05 cameronetchart

That’s the common request when using dropbox’s api, and even so, that doesn’t actually specify anything related to “full write access to my entire Dropbox” it’s asking if it has permission to a). create a folder, b). Upload files to that folder on your behalf. It’s the standard permission request with dropbox’s api. Even once you delete that shared folder, the access is revoked.

dlevi309 avatar May 22 '20 05:05 dlevi309

@dlevi309 I tested it this morning with a dummy dropbox account, and according to the dropbox permissions tab, I think the Delta request gives FULL access to all of dropbox; not just an app folder. You're correct that Delta stores all of its information in a folder called "Delta Emulator," but I think the user is giving Delta permission to view/edit everything in Dropbox. This should be an easy fix since Dropbox has a specific permission set for an app only having access to an app-specific folder. Capture

Capture2

cameronetchart avatar May 22 '20 17:05 cameronetchart