Klaus Rettinghaus

Results 208 comments of Klaus Rettinghaus

I have thought about this some more. If `enclose` means "the whole note is parenthesized/bracketed" there will be problem when it comes to rendering when the stem size is changed....

Thanks @pe-ro. I was aware of the "abstract concept" of a work and completely agree. But coudn't one argue that the first edition of a work is somewhat documentary? Well,...

I think it is a useful option. Maybe just comment it out until a fix is by the hand?

I agree with @annplaksin

From [this comment](https://github.com/music-encoding/music-encoding/issues/968#issuecomment-1220767807) I conclude that this PR solves the problem with `` and `` in the neumes model. Before we continue, this should be merged. Waiting for a second...

@craigsapp This is the same behavior that was acceptable in https://github.com/rism-digital/verovio/issues/620. Why should it be different now? I'm not quite sure what the best solution should be here in MEI....

Well, that is a completely different case, that should be encoded with `sameas` I guess: ```xml Verovio Transcoded from Humdrum ``` But then something more messing shows up: ![Debussy](https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/7693447/145028604-21969f76-6880-47d3-9731-d23b8bee9295.png) Trying...

We expect unison noteheads to be merged automatically whenever possible. If they have different accidentals obviously this shouldn't happen. But what about same _sounding_ accidentals but _different_ visuals? Is the...

Addendum: how would you encode invisible pedal directions (for MIDI output)? As `@form` belongs to the visual domain, perhaps the value `"none"` should also added …

Another question just popped up: If one wants to use a single (styled) 'P' instead of the 'Ped' glyph, should always `@glyph.name` or `@glyph.num` be used, or would it make...