mastodon-twitter-poster icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
mastodon-twitter-poster copied to clipboard

Option to include tweet URL when posting from Twitter to Mastodon

Open Cassolotl opened this issue 6 years ago • 12 comments

For the Twitter --> Mastodon option, would you consider adding an "include URL of original tweet" setting? Maybe just on tweets that have polls in them?

I post a lot of Twitter polls, which can cause confusion on Mastodon, and I think it would help for people on Mastodon to be able to click to open the Twitter poll!

Cassolotl avatar Oct 29 '17 15:10 Cassolotl

Would you prefer that the option enabled the URL in all tweets or only in polls?

renatolond avatar Oct 30 '17 09:10 renatolond

@renatolond I think it would make sense to be enable it only for polls. Maybe having something like this

  • [ ] Include original tweet link
    • [ ] Polls
    • [ ] Retweets
    • [ ] Quote retweets
    • [ ] Images
    • [ ] Regular tweets

thiagomgd avatar Oct 30 '17 10:10 thiagomgd

I think I would prefer it only in polls. It's the only thing I can think of where Twitter shows something that Mastodon can't copy.

Cassolotl avatar Oct 30 '17 14:10 Cassolotl

Yeah, me too, but I was just checking :) Okay, it's on the queue, the idea will be to create a new option that will be disabled by default to enable twitter links when on polls :)

renatolond avatar Oct 30 '17 14:10 renatolond

Thank you! :)

Cassolotl avatar Oct 30 '17 14:10 Cassolotl

I have bad news :( I was taking a look today on this one and there's no support for polls in the public twitter API: https://twittercommunity.com/t/poll-support/78235/8 I won't be able to fix this one for now :disappointed:

renatolond avatar Nov 19 '17 11:11 renatolond

Oh no, that's sad! Thank you for trying.

When I post a poll on Twitter and it gets cross-posted to Mastodon, I've been replying to the post on Mastodon with a link to the Twitter poll tweet, so it's not so bad really.

Cassolotl avatar Nov 19 '17 13:11 Cassolotl

I could still try to create an option to always post the tweet link, but since I cannot tell them apart it would always be there for "normal" tweets (not an RT, reply or quote)

renatolond avatar Nov 19 '17 13:11 renatolond

I think if that was an option I would probably just keep doing things the way I'm doing them now - I do polls much less often than normal tweets, and my normal tweets don't need URLs when crossposting.

Cassolotl avatar Nov 19 '17 14:11 Cassolotl

Just remembered something I saw in Tweetdeck once and tested it - somehow they have a way of detecting polls, even though they can't post them fully.

screen shot 2017-11-25 at 11 15 26

I have no idea if whatever they do is possible with this crossposter, but I thought I'd mention it because it seems relevant and it might help? :S

Cassolotl avatar Nov 25 '17 11:11 Cassolotl

The thing is that I don't know if tweetdeck uses the public api, considering they are from twitter. The enterprise api (basically, premium api) has information about polls: http://support.gnip.com/enrichments/poll_metadata.html

So I think they might be using that one for tweetdeck, which would give them access to the poll information.

renatolond avatar Nov 25 '17 12:11 renatolond

@renatolond Ohhhh that makes sense! Damnit. :(

Cassolotl avatar Nov 25 '17 12:11 Cassolotl