react.dev
react.dev copied to clipboard
[Suggestion]: remove the caveat for writing ref in render path
Summary
In the doc for ref https://react.dev/reference/react/useRef#caveats, it calls out to not read/write ref in rendering phase without a very clear "bad example"
Page
No response
Details
However, there is use case where the caller just needs a static ref at component level to wrap a dynamic value: for example, I need to read/write a static ref in rendering path (keep it in-sync with the current render context value)
In another word, the argument could be "a need to read/sync a "render context" value into a static variable attached to the functional component", + the "ref" value is not use in the "return" of the functional component
const { componentId, renderId } = useContext(componentContext);
const context = { componentId, renderId } <--- dynamic
const contextRef = useRef(context); <--- static
contextRef.current = context;
useQuery({
context: contextRef <--- static ref to avoid equal check, the ref value is only used for logging
})
e.g. https://github.com/apollographql/apollo-client/issues/11835
and there are popular library like useLatest implemented by writing ref in render path
Can we remove or update the caveat to make it more clear? E.g. adding
If you don't attempt to use the "mutable" ref in determining the function return, it is fine to use it to sync rendering context