raulk

@jrhea Definitely 2 for now. Implementing Java bindings should be straightforward as [Netty](https://netty.io/) supports Unix domain sockets, there's ample support for Protobuf in Java. Option 1 is an interesting experiment....

@MBakhshi96 we are not aware of any issues that could cause this. Can you post a test case showing the issue in a github repo? It needs to be reproduced...

Strongly agree with this proposal. Here's a little sketch of how I see this design operating. Did I get it right? 

Ok, that makes sense. Rationale: defining validators on the _leaves_ (subscribers and publishers) would prevent us from attaching validators to relay-only topics (i.e. a topic we're helping disseminate, but we're...

@vyzo is looking into this right now!

@mcdee Gossipsub scoring is scoped to the gossipsub level, and is used to drive mesh peer selection, i.e. which peers do I select to be part of my view of...

@mcdee I responded in libp2p/go-libp2p-core#99, to keep the convo in place. Thanks for raising here, though! I had missed your comment.

@adam-hanna this is the issue we discussed.

@magik6k wanted this a few days ago as well. I agree with @vyzo. For p2p pubsub to work collaboratively and fairly, peers subscribed to a topic MUST participate in the...

Thank you so much for this detailed write-up. To make sure I'm not missing the forest for the trees, I'm going to restate a summary of what you are proposing:...