Linux kernel recompilation instructions are wrong/incomplete

[RaduLucianR]

I recently tried to recompile the Raspberry Pi Linux kernel to enable the PREEMPT_RT patch, but by following the instructions on the documentation page for this very thing I was lead to wrong steps and some things are missing.

I tried both to compile the kernel on my Raspberry Pi (version 4 B+, 64-bit), and to cross-compile it on my x86 laptop with Ubuntu 22.04 and then installing it on the SD card.

After finishing the compilation/cross-compilation, the documentation states that "If you now reboot, your Raspberry Pi should be running your freshly-compiled kernel.", but this is not the case. In both cases (compile and cross-compile) the kernel would not be correctly installed/linked, and the Raspberry Pi would just start up with its normal kernel.

I checked with ls /boot/vmlinuz* to see all available kernels, but the just installed kernel was not there, for compilation nor cross-compilation.

I found out that one could use the flash-kernel command to force the RPi to use the correct kernel. However, the flash-kernel command cannot find the freshly installed kernel because it doesn't have a vmlinuz.

The steps that worked for me to correctly compile and flash the kernel are the following:

1. Cross-compile the Raspberry Pi Linux kernel like described in the docs, BUT use the flag LOCALVERSION=”-raspi”. We need this for the flash-kernel command. This command can force flash our newly installed kernel, but only if it's the "correct flavor". To make a kernel the "correct flavor" for RPis, it needs to have the "-raspi" suffix.
2. Make a .deb package out of the freshly compiled kernel.
3. Copy the .deb package on the RPi and install it.
4. Reboot.
5. Execute the flash-kernel -force <kernel_name> command with the kernel's name.
6. Reboot.
7. Now the RPi should start with the newly installed kernel.

My suggestions for the RPi docs:

1. Mention the option to make a .deb package out of the cross-compiled Linux kernel and how to install it on the Raspberry Pi.
2. Mention that one might need to use the flash-kernel utility to force the Linux kernel installation. In that case the kernel needs to be compiled with the LOCALVERSION=”-raspi”flag, so flash-kernel recognizes the kernel as having the correct flavor.

Some nice additions specific to the PREEMPT_RT patch would be to mention that one needs to disable KVM so that the Full RT option for the Linux kernel becomes available. I know this is not Raspberry Pi-specific but I think that using the PREEMPT_RT patch on a RPi will become more common in the future.

[by]

Thanks, and please add a provision how to properly create initramfs requirements for custom kernels, thank you!

[lurch]

See also #3249

[github-actions[bot]]

This issue has been automatically marked as stale because it has not had recent activity. It will be closed if no further activity occurs. Thank you for your contributions.

[nathan-contino]

Still looking into this. We recently improved the kernel recompilation instructions, but that was just from a copy and organisation perspective; I'll take another pass soon to incorporate this information.

[by]

Any chance of seeing a description how to create initramfs for custom kernels anytime soon? – Thanks!

[lurch]

Any chance of seeing a description how to create initramfs for custom kernels anytime soon? – Thanks!

We've been a bit busy with other things recently... :sweat_smile:

[by]

Any chance of seeing a description how to create initramfs for custom kernels anytime soon? – Thanks!

We've been a bit busy with other things recently... 😅

Any chance, initramfs for custom kernels gets picked up again?

[by]

Just checking in if there might be a chance this year?

[lurch]

Just checking in if there might be a chance this year?

We're currently busy with getting Raspberry Pi OS Trixie ready for release. But maybe after that?