documentation icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
documentation copied to clipboard

Recommended Lenses: FOV vs Field Angle terminology

Open brianlow opened this issue 2 years ago • 2 comments

The Recommended Lenses section:

  • uses two different terms for the same concept: Field Angle (CS lenses) and Field of View (M12 lenses). I believe they can both use the same term
  • uses two different formats for this value: WxH (CS lenses) and DxHxW (M12 lenses). Use the same format for both. If the diagonal isn't available for CS lenses, perhaps use WxH / WxH (D diagonal)

brianlow avatar Nov 04 '23 04:11 brianlow

Some further comments on C/CS Lenses Table. Edited :-to follow @brianlow format suggestions

Propose that the entry for Aperture in the 16mm Telephoto lens column should be F1.4 to F16 rather than F1.4 to 1.6.

The Field Angle entries for various (unrelated to HQ or GS) arcane x/x.x sensor formats aren't particularly useful and may even be misleading.

Propose that the entries be the achieved field angles (Field of View) for each lens type on the specific HQ and GS sensor formats. e.g.

			16mm telephoto		6mm wide angle
Field of View 	HQ	  22.2° x 16.7°		    55° x 45°	
		GS	  17.8° x 13.4°		    45° x 34°

These values are only estimates, not measured values, for the two lens types!

Similarly for the M12 Lenses table the achieved Fields of View seem to be for the maximum image size formats that the lenses have been designed for. So only the Fish Eye entry has the correct values, (as the HQ sensor is an 1/2.3" device).

Propose that the table entries become:-

HQ Field of View H x V (D)

72.64°/57.12°/42.44° becomes 49° x 36° (62°)

18.3°/14.7°/11.1° becomes 14.4° x 10.9° (17.9°)

184.6°/140°/102.6° becomes 140° x 102.6° (184.6°)

sandyol55 avatar Nov 16 '23 15:11 sandyol55

This issue has been automatically marked as stale because it has not had recent activity. It will be closed if no further activity occurs. Thank you for your contributions.

github-actions[bot] avatar Jan 21 '24 02:01 github-actions[bot]