qBittorrent icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
qBittorrent copied to clipboard

Stable PPA without daily versions

Open devster31 opened this issue 5 years ago • 3 comments

qBittorrent version and Operating System

N/A

If on linux, libtorrent and Qt version

N/A

What is the problem

The PPA provided for debian-like systems gets updated every day, often multiple times per day. While I understand the reasoning for qbittorrent-unstable I don't believe qbittorrent-stable should follow the same approach.

What is the expected behavior

Updates should follow GitHub (or similar) releases and not follow master branch or a cron schedule. Stable release with dates like so 4.1.5.99~201904170702-6696-4253515~ubuntu18.04.1 are not really helpful.

Steps to reproduce

N/A


Want to back this issue? Post a bounty on it! We accept bounties via Bountysource.

devster31 avatar Apr 30 '19 10:04 devster31

Why though... ? Are you bothered by the numbers? Do numbers scare you?

Balls0fSteel avatar May 01 '19 09:05 Balls0fSteel

Numbers imply daily builds, daily builds imply instability. If something changes between the builds it means the version being built is not a stable release, if no change is happening it means the new build is useless. In both cases apt-get reports a new version and this means every 12 hours or more a new update. I don't believe this is the definition of a stable release. In addition old ones get deleted as far as I can see, which means I cannot do reproducible docker images, for instance, without building from source or downloading from Debian testing/newer Ubuntu distro packages.

devster31 avatar May 02 '19 22:05 devster31

It's not a bad thing, it's a good thing, as you are getting more frequent improvements that are stable.

pizzadude avatar May 19 '19 02:05 pizzadude

We have changed mentality towards stable releases. They usually don't have backported every single commit made in the master branch. They commits are seldom and fix-only more-or-less. Hence, low traffic in the stable PPA. And under this mentality it is better to get the fixes as soon as they appear because --usually- they are important.

sledgehammer999 avatar Aug 23 '22 15:08 sledgehammer999