executorch icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
executorch copied to clipboard

Android Llama2 demo app fails to install on S23/S24 with Android 14

Open huydhn opened this issue 1 year ago • 2 comments

🐛 Describe the bug

We have an Android CI job to run llama2 demo app on actual S22 devices with stories model on OSS CI at https://github.com/pytorch/executorch/blob/main/.github/workflows/android.yml#L149. However, the job fails to install the app on newer S23/S24 with Android 14. So, the testing is limited only to S22 for now. Attempting to add those newer devices would fail the job, for example https://github.com/pytorch/executorch/actions/runs/10220354591/job/28281804591.

Looking at the logcat output:

  • S23 https://gha-artifacts.s3.amazonaws.com/device_farm/10220354591/1/arn_aws_devicefarm_us-west-2_308535385114_artifact_02a2cf0f-6d9b-45ee-ba1a-a086587469e6_c83e8f5a-ebcb-4de7-a952-ae1a6c29421e_00003_00000_00000_00000_Logcat.logcat
  • S24 https://gha-artifacts.s3.amazonaws.com/device_farm/10220354591/1/arn_aws_devicefarm_us-west-2_308535385114_artifact_02a2cf0f-6d9b-45ee-ba1a-a086587469e6_c83e8f5a-ebcb-4de7-a952-ae1a6c29421e_00001_00000_00000_00000_Logcat.logcat

The error seems to be this line, which indicates an issue with how the app is built:

D PackageInstallerSession: Marking session 1288101458 as failed: INSTALL_FAILED_DEPRECATED_SDK_VERSION: App package must target at least SDK version 23, but found 0

cc @kirklandsign @guangy10

Versions

Latest trunk version

huydhn avatar Aug 02 '24 20:08 huydhn

Because of this issue, I need to split the Android pool into 2 for now https://github.com/pytorch/executorch/wiki/How-to-create-a-custom-device-pool-on-AWS-Device-Farm#existing-device-pools. One with only S22 that we can readily use in CI, the other includes also S23/S24 that we can use once the app is ready.

@kirklandsign During your test, you could use the latter pool for testing, its ARN is arn:aws:devicefarm:us-west-2:308535385114:devicepool:02a2cf0f-6d9b-45ee-ba1a-a086587469e6/98f8788c-2e25-4a3c-8bb2-0d1e8897c0db

huydhn avatar Aug 02 '24 20:08 huydhn

@kirklandsign During your test, you could use the latter pool for testing, its ARN is arn:aws:devicefarm:us-west-2:308535385114:devicepool:02a2cf0f-6d9b-45ee-ba1a-a086587469e6/98f8788c-2e25-4a3c-8bb2-0d1e8897c0db

Thank you for your suggestion @huydhn !

kirklandsign avatar Aug 02 '24 21:08 kirklandsign

I feel like it's not related to adb install failure. However, I can't determine what's wrong from logs.

kirklandsign avatar Sep 05 '24 02:09 kirklandsign

^ We have the proper SDK level set up in the apk

kirklandsign avatar Sep 05 '24 02:09 kirklandsign

 09-14 05:02:07.908  2404  2796 I PackageManager: Integrity check passed for file:///data/app/vmdl1439995569.tmp
 09-14 05:02:07.909  2404  2797 I PackageManager: START INSTALL PACKAGE: observer{105561742}
 09-14 05:02:07.909  2404  2797 I PackageManager:           stagedDir{/data/app/vmdl1439995569.tmp}
 09-14 05:02:07.909  2404  2797 I PackageManager:           pkg{com.trellis}
 09-14 05:02:07.909  2404  2797 I PackageManager:           versionCode{1}
 09-14 05:02:07.909  2404  2797 I PackageManager:           Request from{null}
 09-14 05:02:07.911 13269 20406 I GOS:GameIntentService: onHandleIntent. GameIntentService. type: 15, pkgName: null
 09-14 05:02:07.912 13269 20406 W GOS:RequestHeader: tryToAddMcc(), can't find mcc
 09-14 05:02:07.912 13269 20406 W GOS:RequestHeader: tryToAddMnc(), can't find mnc
 09-14 05:02:07.913  2404  2796 W PackageManager: App com.trellis targets deprecated sdk version
 09-14 05:02:07.913  2404  2796 W PackageManager: App package must target at least SDK version 23, but found 0
 09-14 05:02:07.915  2404  2796 I PackageManager: result of install: -29{105561742}
 09-14 05:02:07.915  2404  2796 D PackageInstallerSession: Marking session 1439995569 as failed: INSTALL_FAILED_DEPRECATED_SDK_VERSION: App package must target at least SDK version 23, but found 0

Seems that the failure is from another app (com.trellis) ?

kirklandsign avatar Sep 17 '24 04:09 kirklandsign