junction icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
junction copied to clipboard

Change the numbering order in the proposal list page

Open cnu opened this issue 8 years ago • 12 comments

Fixes a minor annoyance in the proposal listing page, where the number next to the proposal title is numbered from the top. When a new proposal is submitted, the old proposals are shifted down and the entire numbering is changed.

By using a revcounter in the forloop, we can show that the first talk submitted is always displayed the number 1 even if it is pushed to the bottom and the latest talk submitted will always be displayed the highest number.

cnu avatar Jul 01 '16 23:07 cnu

Coverage Status

Coverage remained the same at 70.695% when pulling c4184a227d80e94eb0ef8ac273d154ca67407da9 on cnu:master into 7dd648bcfd0a995eb21926e2503a0a9a5b45376c on pythonindia:master.

coveralls avatar Jul 01 '16 23:07 coveralls

Could you show a screenshot ?

kracekumar avatar Jul 02 '16 05:07 kracekumar

btw. instead of reversing the numbering i'm more in favour of removing it all together, what's the purpose of displaying that counter anyways? If we really need to total number of proposals it can be displayed at meta info, something like Total Proposals: X

thoughts?

theskumar avatar Jul 02 '16 06:07 theskumar

@theskumar Agree. Except that it will help us identify when did the Xth(Ex:10th, 100th) proposal is submitted.

sivaa avatar Jun 23 '17 14:06 sivaa

Sounds legit. Older proposals should be at top. What do you think @palnabarun @pradyunsg

ananyo2012 avatar Mar 20 '20 19:03 ananyo2012

Oh yeah. This is a needed change.

Wonder why it was never merged in.

palnabarun avatar Mar 20 '20 19:03 palnabarun

But, wait this looks a little odd to me. image

palnabarun avatar Mar 20 '20 19:03 palnabarun

But, wait this would look very odd.

Why so ?

ananyo2012 avatar Mar 20 '20 19:03 ananyo2012

Do we plan to have voting on the proposals?

If we do, we should drop the numbers and have it show up in a shuffled order.

pradyunsg avatar Mar 20 '20 20:03 pradyunsg

But, wait this looks a little odd to me. image

Ah I see the proposal order is not reversed rather the numberings are reversed.

ananyo2012 avatar Mar 24 '20 18:03 ananyo2012

Do we plan to have voting on the proposals?

If we do, we should drop the numbers and have it show up in a shuffled order.

Votes are rarely used for proposal selection. Last year's CFP disabled voting and did not have voting promotions as well. Voting is usually used to break ties when deciding between 2 very competitive proposals.

ananyo2012 avatar Mar 25 '20 05:03 ananyo2012

@palnabarun @pradyunsg On a deeper thought recent proposals should actually come on top so that it will be accessible for reviewers and visitors to see newer proposals rather than scrolling all the way down.

This change reverses the numbering so that numbers are in descending order. There is a earlier comment which suggests removing numbering all together. Except that will not allow to see when Xth proposal was submitted which I guess isn't required anyway? What do you think ?

ananyo2012 avatar Mar 25 '20 05:03 ananyo2012