junction icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
junction copied to clipboard

enable threaded commenting

Open ChillarAnand opened this issue 9 years ago • 3 comments

we need to provide threaded commenting so that readers/reviewers can reply to other comments & emails should be send accordingly.

ChillarAnand avatar Feb 21 '15 17:02 ChillarAnand

Given that public comments are relatively less and not used for deciding the status of proposal, this doesn't seems to be required. Also this needs additional DB changes.

Instead supporting #226 is fair enough. @palnabarun @pradyunsg Any comments on this ?

ananyo2012 avatar Mar 20 '20 19:03 ananyo2012

I have seen threaded comments on funnel which is Hasgeek's CFP system. All bidirectional communication between proposers and reviewers gets mediated through that. For example, here

I am not really sure about our use case though.

palnabarun avatar Mar 20 '20 19:03 palnabarun

There is a separate reviewer comments section which is private. So communication is between one reviewer and proposer usually. Should be good even without nested comments.

ananyo2012 avatar Mar 20 '20 19:03 ananyo2012