packaging.python.org
packaging.python.org copied to clipboard
Consolidate the "Project Summaries" by removing items and grouping the remaining ones
Should we consolidate the list "Project Summaries" a bit? Currently it is very long, and the order is quite random. I'd propose two changes to mitigate that:
- remove things that are not really relevant
- structure the items by use case
Below there's a list of all projects currently listed, with a remark about last update and "github popularity". In my opinion we could remove half of the projects here and group the remaining ones by use case.
For the non-pypa projects I suggest to remove the ones that are clearly unmaintained and (rather aggressively) the ones with a very low "github popularity". For the pypa projects, we could remove the more "fringe" cases projects, but we may not have to. Again, the goal being to have a useful overview for the users about the tools of the trade instead of a random selection of things with little relation to each other.
Project | last updated | forks/stars | remove? |
---|---|---|---|
bandersnatch | recently | 112/311 | is this really relevant for installation and packaging? |
build | recently | 70/319 | |
cibuildwheel | recently | 150/1.1k | |
distlib (wrong url) | recently | 13/20 | |
flit | recently | 97/1.7k | |
hatch | recently | 116/2.6k | |
packaging | recently | 199/396 | |
pip | recently | 2.6k/8k | |
pipenv | recently | 1.7k/23k | |
pipfile | recently | 148/3.1k | not part of any standard, i.e. PEP |
pipx | recently | 239/5.1k | |
packaging.python.org | recently | 560/1.1k | does this belong into the list? |
readme_renderer | recently | 91/133 | low relevance? |
setuptools | recently | 888/1.7k | |
trove-classifiers | recently | 61/68 | low relevance? |
twine | recently | 269/1.3k | |
virtualenv | recently | 944/4.2k | |
warehouse | recently | 871/3k | |
wheel | recently | 116/323 | |
--- | --- | --- | |
buildout | recently | 172/537 | yes - low relevance |
conda | yes - different ecosystem | ||
devpi | recently | 104/562 | yes - low relevance |
enscons | recently | 3/23 | yes - low relevance |
hashdist | 2016 | 43/105 | yes - probably unmaintained |
multibuild | 2021-10 | 77/2 | yes - low relevance |
pdm | recently | 104/2.5k | |
pex | recently | 221/2.1k | |
pip-tools | recently | 521/5.9k | |
pipwheels | recently | 22/221 | yes - low relevance |
poetry | recently | 1.6k/19.9k | |
pypiserver | recently | 251/1.4k | |
pyscaffold | recently | 157/1.5k | |
scikit-build | recently | 95/324 | yes - low relevance |
shiv | recently | 85/1.4k | |
spack | recently | 1.6k/2.7k | |
zest.releaser | recently | 60/185 | yes - low relevance |
The grouping by use case is a bit more difficult as we'd need to settle for a set of tags or so first before we can start grouping the items accordingly.
the order is quite random
It's not? It's two alphabetical lists -- PyPA projects followed by non-PyPA projects (at least, it's supposed to be) that are related to Python Packaging and designed as general workflow tools.
Anyway, I think categorising the projects by usecase instead of whether they're a PyPA project would be an improvement. The main question with that is what the categories should be, which is honestly unclear at a first glance.
I don't think we should be removing any of the projects that were "recently active".
Yes the categories are indeed not trivial. One could start with a catch-all category "miscellaneous" and put everything in there. And try to work out some more useful ones. I would order the categories by importance, and we should allow packages to appear in several categories if they fulfill several roles. That will also make our life easier finding useful categories. Here's an example (this is not meant to be anything final, just a demonstrator):
PEP 518 compatible build system
some description of the category goes here
- setuptools
- flit
- hatch
- build
- ...
Packaging
some description of the category goes here
- setuptools
- wheel
- flit
- hatch
- poetry
- ...
virtual environments
some description of the category goes here
- virtualenv
- pipx
- poetry
- ...
miscellaneous
...