interoperability-peps icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
interoperability-peps copied to clipboard

PEP 458: Final Reviewer Edits

Open vladimir-v-diaz opened this issue 10 years ago • 2 comments

@dstufft @r1chardj0n3s

I edited and made pull requests to add all of the text, images, and modifications I felt were still needed in the draft. All that remains is for pull requests #20 and #17 to be reviewed and merged, and for Donald to incorporate his edits; he can review the draft for technical issues and add any text he feels is missing.

Things to review:

  • Finalize section "Appendix C: PEP 470 and Projects Hosted Externally". It lists options for how to handle externally hosted projects, but we need to clearly choose one method.
  • Anticipate the problems that may crop up while implementing PEP 458. (Is the mirror protocol good enough? CDN Purging?)
  • Ensure PEP 458 provides enough flexibility so that PEP 480 does not require major changes.
  • PEP 458 has relied on referencing the TUF white paper and spec to get a grasp of what’s going on. Ensure this is no longer the case.
  • PEP 458 reads more like suggestions about how we might go about implementing TUF rather than an actionable plan for implementing TUF.
  • Clearly state the impact of PEP 458 without having to go through and understand the intricacies of TUF or how PEP 458 integrates TUF.

vladimir-v-diaz avatar Jan 27 '15 21:01 vladimir-v-diaz

Changed Remaining Issues: to Things to review: Hopefully there shouldn't be much left to include, mostly finalization of sections / text that read more like suggestions.

vladimir-v-diaz avatar Jan 27 '15 21:01 vladimir-v-diaz

I plan on digging into this in the near future fwiw.

dstufft avatar Jan 27 '15 22:01 dstufft