pml-book icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
pml-book copied to clipboard

Book 1, Solution in pdf to 3.5

Open dfd opened this issue 3 years ago • 2 comments

Not sure if this is the correct place to report this issue for this:

It says: E [Y ] = E [W X] = E [X] E [X] = 0

Should say:

E [Y ] = E [W X] = E [W] E [X] = 0

dfd avatar Jul 30 '22 21:07 dfd

they look identical - what should it say?

murphyk avatar Aug 09 '22 05:08 murphyk

I'll clarify the difference with bold font:

current: E [Y ] = E [W X] = E [X] E [X] = 0

proposed: E [Y ] = E [W X] = E [W] E [X] = 0

E[W] and E[X] are both 0, so the original equality is not wrong, I suppose. Or maybe I'm not understanding how you go from E[W X] to E[X] E[X] symbolically. But it seems more straight forward to me to move from E[W X] to E[W] E[X] (which we can do when X and W are independent) than to E[X] E[X].

Does that make sense? Or am I missing something?

dfd avatar Aug 09 '22 17:08 dfd

Oh I see. It's just a typo. It should be E [Y ] = E [W X] = E [W] E [X] = 0.

murphyk avatar Apr 17 '23 04:04 murphyk