Prebid.js icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
Prebid.js copied to clipboard

OwnAdX Bid Adapter : initial release

Open ownAdx-prebid opened this issue 1 year ago • 9 comments

Add new adapter

ownAdx-prebid avatar Jun 21 '24 16:06 ownAdx-prebid

Whoa there, partner! 🌵🤠 We wrangled some duplicated code in your PR:

Reducing code duplication by importing common functions from a library not only makes our code cleaner but also easier to maintain. Please move the common code from both files into a library and import it in each. Keep up the great work! 🚀

github-actions[bot] avatar Jun 21 '24 16:06 github-actions[bot]

Whoa there, partner! 🌵🤠 We wrangled some duplicated code in your PR:

Reducing code duplication by importing common functions from a library not only makes our code cleaner but also easier to maintain. Please move the common code from both files into a library and import it in each. Keep up the great work! 🚀

Remove duplicate lines

ownAdx-prebid avatar Jun 25 '24 10:06 ownAdx-prebid

reordering lines in a json object appears to be a malicious commit

Regarding patmmccann's comment, did you squash your commits to "hide" the malicious commit ?

JulieLorin avatar Jul 03 '24 08:07 JulieLorin

Why whould you need to update renderer.js files ? This doesn't seem to be what is needed to add a new adapter. As well as adding gulp-cli as a production dependency

Also, to add a new bid adapter, you must create a pull request in prebid docs linking your adapter, and link it in this PR

@JulieLorin As per your recommendation, we have done the changes from our end. Below is pull request URL in prebid docs for OwnAdX: https://github.com/prebid/prebid.github.io/pull/5472

ownAdx-prebid avatar Jul 03 '24 08:07 ownAdx-prebid

reordering lines in a json object appears to be a malicious commit

Regarding patmmccann's comment, did you squash your commits to "hide" the malicious commit ?

We have made the changes as per your recommendations in last commit

ownAdx-prebid avatar Jul 03 '24 12:07 ownAdx-prebid

reordering lines in a json object appears to be a malicious commit

Regarding patmmccann's comment, did you squash your commits to "hide" the malicious commit ?

We have made the changes as per your recommendations in last commit

There were 3 commits before your push, and there is now only one commit. From what I see, there are still the modifications you made (reordering lines in the object) to trick the code duplication robot. If I am mistaken, can you explain what you changed to resolve patmmccann's comment ?

JulieLorin avatar Jul 03 '24 12:07 JulieLorin

update renderer.js

reordering lines in a json object appears to be a malicious commit

Regarding patmmccann's comment, did you squash your commits to "hide" the malicious commit ?

We have made the changes as per your recommendations in last commit

There were 3 commits before your push, and there is now only one commit. From what I see, there are still the modifications you made (reordering lines in the object) to trick the code duplication robot. If I am mistaken, can you explain what you changed to resolve patmmccann's comment ?

By mistakely at initialy we was added some files which autoupdated like renderer.js to avoid we are reset branch with origin master and added our files owadxBidAdapter.js and owadxBidAdapter_spec.js

we are already make changes for the below sugestions in this commit. 1.Duplicated lines 2.malicious attempt to silence the code duplication robot 3.reordering lines in a json object appears to be a malicious commit 4.Removing renderer.js file changes

ownAdx-prebid avatar Jul 03 '24 12:07 ownAdx-prebid

By mistakely at initialy we was added some files which autoupdated like renderer.js to avoid we are reset branch with origin master and added our files owadxBidAdapter.js and owadxBidAdapter_spec.js

we are already make changes for the below sugestions in this commit. 1.Duplicated lines 2.malicious attempt to silence the code duplication robot 3.reordering lines in a json object appears to be a malicious commit 4.Removing renderer.js file changes

I agree changes are fixed for files like renderer.js or added dependancies. But I don't understand for the rest, what did you change after the comment about the malicious commit ? From what I see, the malicious commit has only been squashed, and not reverted

JulieLorin avatar Jul 03 '24 12:07 JulieLorin

By mistakely at initialy we was added some files which autoupdated like renderer.js to avoid we are reset branch with origin master and added our files owadxBidAdapter.js and owadxBidAdapter_spec.js we are already make changes for the below sugestions in this commit. 1.Duplicated lines 2.malicious attempt to silence the code duplication robot 3.reordering lines in a json object appears to be a malicious commit 4.Removing renderer.js file changes

I agree changes are fixed for files like renderer.js or added dependancies. But I don't understand for the rest, what did you change after the comment about the malicious commit ? From what I see, the malicious commit has only been squashed, and not reverted

We have only remove the changes in renderer.js file & gulp-cli

ownAdx-prebid avatar Jul 03 '24 13:07 ownAdx-prebid

@ownAdx-prebid we'd prefer the robot was complaining so we can identify common patterns rather than reordering things to silence it. Minor duplication doesn't prevent merging. You can trust that @JulieLorin will not be unreasonable in her discretion.

patmmccann avatar Jul 10 '24 04:07 patmmccann

@ownAdx-prebid we'd prefer the robot was complaining so we can identify common patterns rather than reordering things to silence it. Minor duplication doesn't prevent merging. You can trust that @JulieLorin will not be unreasonable in her discretion.

Can you please suggest what changes required

ownAdx-prebid avatar Jul 10 '24 06:07 ownAdx-prebid

@ownAdx-prebid team, the server team is having some trouble contacting you https://github.com/prebid/prebid-server/issues/3774 https://github.com/prebid/prebid-server-java/pull/2868#discussion_r1447109093

patmmccann avatar Jul 12 '24 14:07 patmmccann

@ownAdx-prebid team, the server team is having some trouble contacting you prebid/prebid-server#3774 prebid/prebid-server-java#2868 (comment)

@patmmccann I have assigned OwnAdX prebid server team,will update on this issue.

ownAdx-prebid avatar Jul 15 '24 09:07 ownAdx-prebid

@ownAdx-prebid team, the server team is having some trouble contacting you prebid/prebid-server#3774 prebid/prebid-server-java#2868 (comment)

@patmmccann I have assigned OwnAdX prebid server team,will update on this issue.

@patmmccann Done from our end. Anything is required from our end for submitting the OwnAdX PrebidJS Adapter?

ownAdx-prebid avatar Jul 17 '24 10:07 ownAdx-prebid

@ownAdx-prebid team, the server team is having some trouble contacting you prebid/prebid-server#3774 prebid/prebid-server-java#2868 (comment)

@patmmccann I have assigned OwnAdX prebid server team,will update on this issue.

@patmmccann Done from our end. Anything is required from our end for submitting the OwnAdX PrebidJS Adapter?

Is it possible to have an answer on this question ? image Thanks

JulieLorin avatar Jul 17 '24 13:07 JulieLorin

@ownAdx-prebid team, the server team is having some trouble contacting you prebid/prebid-server#3774 prebid/prebid-server-java#2868 (comment)

@patmmccann I have assigned OwnAdX prebid server team,will update on this issue.

@patmmccann Done from our end. Anything is required from our end for submitting the OwnAdX PrebidJS Adapter?

Is it possible to have an answer on this question ? image Thanks

@JulieLorin For 'token' is use for identify the tag for our end & 'aType' this field is use for identification flag for another Ad type in future use.If this field is hampering for any where in Adapter so we can remove it.

ownAdx-prebid avatar Jul 18 '24 08:07 ownAdx-prebid

@JulieLorin For 'token' is use for identify the tag for our end & 'aType' this field is use for identification flag for another Ad type in future use.If this field is hampering for any where in Adapter so we can remove it.

Thank you for providing an explanation. I think it is OK to keep them

JulieLorin avatar Jul 18 '24 08:07 JulieLorin